The Monastic Pint Answers from church history on today's questions

1 John 1:9

What Christian writers said, from about AD 386 to 1949.

48 passages · 31 writers · 7 centuries

The short answer

The writers read 1 John 1:9 as a promise that God forgives those who confess their sins to him. They say God is faithful because he promised pardon to the penitent, and just because Christ's sacrifice has been made. They describe the confession as honest, full, and made to God, though Tillotson calls John's confession general, not particular, and Bayly asks for both. They add that John names cleansing as well as forgiveness. Several say believers need to confess and seek forgiveness as they continue to sin.

Confession to God

25 passages · 19 writers · 300s to 1900s

Calvin and Spurgeon say the confession is made to God, honestly and fully, Barnes says pardon requires a full acknowledgment, and Tillotson calls John's confession general, not particular.

c. 407 · Augustine of Hippo, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John (In Epistulam Iohannis ad Parthos Tractatus X) 1.6

Consequently, if thou hast confessed thyself a sinner, the truth is in thee: for the Truth itself is light. Thy life hath not yet shone in perfect brightness, because there are sins in thee; but yet thou hast already begun to be enlightened, because there is in thee the confession of sins. For see what follows: “If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to purge us from all iniquity.” Not only the past, but haply if we have contracted any from this life; because a man, so long as he bears the flesh, cannot but have some at any rate light sins.

1559 · John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion 3.4.9

“If we confess our sins,” says John, “he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins,” (1 John 1:9). To whom are we to confess? to Him surely;—that is, we are to fall down before him with a grieved and humbled heart, and sincerely accusing and condemning ourselves, seek forgiveness of his goodness and mercy.

1820 · John Tillotson, Works, Volume 7 159

“If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins.” Here, indeed, is confession; but general, not particular, as appears by the opposition, “If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us: but if we confess our sins;” that is, if we acknowledge ourselves to have been sinners. And then there is not a word of confessing to the priest; the confession here meant is plainly to God, because it follows, “he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins;” that is, God, who is necessarily understood in the former part of the sentence, as if it had run thus, “If we confess our sins to God, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins.”

Faithful and just

12 passages · 11 writers · 1500s to 1800s

Reynolds, Watson, Calvin, and Spurgeon explain God's faithfulness as keeping his promise and his justice as resting on Christ's sacrifice.

1551 · John Calvin, Commentary on 1 John 1.9

9 If we confess He again promises to the faithful that God will be propitious to them, provided they acknowledge themselves to be sinners. It is of great moment to be fully persuaded, that when we have sinned, there is a reconciliation with God ready and prepared for us: we shall otherwise carry always a hell within us. Few, indeed, consider how miserable and wretched is a doubting conscience; but the truth is, that hell reigns where there is no peace with God. The more, then, it becomes us to receive with the whole heart this promise which offers free pardon to all who confess their sins. Moreover, this is founded even on the justice of God, because God who promises is true and just.

1692 · Thomas Watson, A Body of Divinity, Contained in Sermons upon the Westminster Assembly's Catechism 3.8

As God is a just God, he will pardon him. Homo agnoscit, Deus ignoscit [Man acknowledges his sin, God spares him]. ‘If we confess our sins (i.e. confess and forsake), he is just to forgive us our sins.' I John 1:9. Not only merciful but just. Why just? Because he has promised to forgive such. Prov 28:13. If thy heart has been broken for and from sin, thou mayest not only plead God's mercy, but his justice for the pardoning of thy sin. Show him his hand and seal, and he cannot deny himself.

1859 · Charles Haddon Spurgeon, Spurgeon's Sermons, Volume 5 (1859) 255

The second text says that not only can God be just, but it says something more: it says, “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.” Now, if I understand this text, it means this: that IT IS AN ACT OF JUSTICE ON GOD’S PART TO FORGIVE THE SINNER WHO MAKES A CONFESSION OF HIS SIN TO GOD. Mark! not that the sinner deserves forgiveness: that can never be. Sin can never merit anything but punishment, and repentance is no atonement for sin. Not that God is bound from any necessity of his nature to forgive every one that repents, because repentance has not in itself sufficient efficacy and power to merit forgiveness at the hand of God. Yet, nevertheless, it is a truth that, because God is just, he must forgive every sinner who confesses his sin. And if he did not—and mark, it is a bold thing to say, but it is warranted by the text—if a sinner should be led truly and solemnly to make confession of his sins and cast himself on Christ, if God did not forgive him, then he were not the God that he is represented to be in the Word of God: he were a God unjust, and that may God forbid, such a thing must not, cannot be.

Cleansing and daily confession

11 passages · 10 writers · 300s to 1900s

Calvin, Wesley, and Hannah Whitall Smith say John adds cleansing to forgiveness, and that believers keep confessing as they keep sinning.

391–430 · Augustine of Hippo, Sermons on Selected Lessons of the New Testament (Sermones 51-147) 64.4

Consider who it is that says, “If we shall say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. But if we shall confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all iniquity.” How does He cleanse? By forgiving, not as though He found nothing to punish, but as finding something to forgive.

1551 · John Calvin, Commentary on 1 John 1.9

God, indeed, forgives freely, but in such a way, that the facility of mercy does not become an enticement to sin. And to cleanse us The verb, to cleanse, seems to be taken in another sense than before; for he had said, that we are cleansed by the blood of Christ, because through him sins are not imputed; but now, having spoken of pardon, he also adds, that God cleanses us from iniquity: so that this second clause is different from the preceding. Thus he intimates that a twofold fruit comes to us from confession, — that God being reconciled by the sacrifice of Christ, forgives us, — and that he renews and reforms us.

1766 · John Wesley, A Plain Account of Christian Perfection 12

If we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all sin.’ And again: ’If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.’ Now, it is evident, the Apostle here speaks of a deliverance wrought in this world: For he saith not, The blood of Christ will cleanse, (at the hour of death, or in the day of judgment,) but it ‘cleanseth,’ at the time present, us living Christians ‘from all sin.’ And it is equally evident, that if any sin remain, we are not cleansed from ‘all’ sin. If any unrighteousness remain in the soul, it is not cleansed from ‘all’ unrighteousness. Neither let any say that this relates to justification only, or the cleansing us from the guilt of sin: First, because this is confounding together what the Apostle clearly distinguishes, who mentions, first, ’to forgive us our sins, and then ‘to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.’

1906 · Hannah Whitall Smith, The God of All Comfort 12

Should even sin unhappily overtake you, you must not let it make you doubt. At once, on the discovery of any sin, take I John 1:9 and act on it. “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.” Confess your sin, therefore, immediately upon the discovery of it, and believe at once that God does forgive it, as He declares, and does again cleanse you from all unrighteousness. No sin, however grievous, can separate us from God for one moment, after it has been treated in this fashion. To allow sin to cause your faith to waver is only to add a new sin to the one already committed. Return at once to God in the way the Bible teaches, and let your faith hold steadfastly to His Word. Believe it, not because you feel it, or see it, but because He says it. Believe it, even when it seems to you that you are believing a lie.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.