The Monastic Pint Answers from church history on today's questions

Contemplative prayer

What Christian writers said, from about AD 198 to 1909.

46 passages · 19 writers · 9 centuries

The short answer

The writers in this group describe contemplative prayer as inward prayer that rests in God's presence with few or no words. Teresa of Avila names stages from recollection to the prayer of quiet and union, in which she says the mind ceases to act. Guyon and de Caussade teach a simple look of faith toward God and silent waiting, and Basil and Clement of Alexandria, earlier writers, speak of recollection of God and of prayer without the voice. Catherine of Siena says the soul should not abandon vocal prayer while imperfect but advance by degrees to mental prayer, de Sales says to let the mind fall into mental prayer if drawn to it while saying vocal prayers, and Scougal says he does not recommend mental prayer so as to supersede the other sort. Owen says that for contemplative prayer as described by the author he answers and others, there is no precept, direction, motive, or example in Scripture.

Teresa of Avila on recollection and quiet

14 passages · 3 writers · 1500s to 1600s

Teresa of Avila says that in the prayer of quiet the soul should be gentle and without noise, not going about with the understanding in search of words and reflections. She says recollection is not gained by thinking of God dwelling within us, which is a good meditation but a different thing, and that quietude and inward peace grow out of recollection. Of union, she says that all the faculties can then do nothing, the understanding is surprised, and the will loves more than the understanding knows. On meditation on Christ, she says that meditating on a mystery of the Passion is a method of prayer that should be to everyone the beginning, the middle, and the end until our Lord guides them to other ways, and that no one can persuade her it is well to omit contemplating the mysteries of Jesus Christ.

1562–1565 · Teresa of Avila, The Life of St. Teresa of Jesus 22.3

I found out afterwards that, if our Lord had not shown me the way, I should have learned but little from books; for I understood really nothing till His Majesty made me learn by experience: neither did I know what I was doing. So, in the beginning, when I attained to some degree of supernatural prayer,—I speak of the prayer of quiet,—I laboured to remove from myself every thought of bodily objects; but I did not dare to lift up my soul, for that I saw would be presumption in me, who was always so wicked. I thought, however, that I had a sense of the presence of God: this was true, and I contrived to be in a state of recollection before Him. This method of prayer is full of sweetness, if God helps us in it, and the joy of it is great. And so, because I was conscious of the profit and delight which this way furnished me, no one could have brought me back to the contemplation of the Sacred Humanity; for that seemed to me to be a real hindrance to prayer.

1577 · Teresa of Avila, The Interior Castle 4.3.7

In the prayer of quiet, when the water flows from the spring itself and not through conduits, the mind ceases to act; it is forced to do so, although it does not understand what is happening, and so wanders hither and thither in bewilderment, finding no place for rest. Meanwhile the will, entirely united to God, is much disturbed by the tumult of the thoughts: no notice, however, should be taken of them, or they would cause the loss of a great part of the favour the soul is enjoying. Let the spirit ignore these distractions and abandon itself in the arms of divine love: His Majesty will teach it how best to act, which chiefly consists in its recognizing its unworthiness of so great a good and occupying itself in thanking Him for it.

The presence of God and silence

21 passages · 10 writers · 100s to 1800s

Guyon says the soul that places itself by faith in the presence of God should remain for a little time in profound and respectful silence, and that distractions are overcome by turning inward rather than by direct contest. De Caussade describes prayer by a simple glance of faith without mental images, a loving waiting on God, and waiting patiently in silence and resignation. Brother Lawrence advises against many words in prayer and says to hold oneself before God like a dumb or paralytic beggar at a rich man's gate. Basil says that prayer is good which imprints a clear idea of God in the soul, Clement of Alexandria says prayer may be uttered without the voice, by the mind turning undistracted toward God, and Philaret of Moscow calls prayer of the heart and mind inward prayer. Arndt reports a devout writer's advice to bring all the powers of the soul into profound repose, and he cites Tauler as saying that supernatural prayer consists in a true union with God by faith.

c. 357–378 · Basil of Caesarea, Letters 2.4

Prayers, too, after reading, find the soul fresher, and more vigorously stirred by love towards God. And that prayer is good which imprints a clear idea of God in the soul; and the having God established in self by means of memory is God’s indwelling. Thus we become God’s temple, when the continuity of our recollection is not severed by earthly cares; when the mind is harassed by no sudden sensations; when the worshipper flees from all things and retreats to God, drawing away all the feelings that invite him to self-indulgence, and passes his time in the pursuits that lead to virtue.]

1685 · Madame Guyon, A Short and Easy Method of Prayer 13

The soul advanced thus far hath no need of any other preparation than its quietude: for now the Presence of God, which is the great effect, or rather continuation of Prayer, begins to be infused, and almost without intermission. The soul enjoys transcendent blessedness, and feels that “it no longer lives, but that Christ liveth in it”; and that the only way to find Him is introversion. No sooner do the bodily eyes close than the soul is wrapt up in Prayer: it is amazed at so great a blessing, and enjoys an internal converse, which external matters cannot interrupt.

c. 1740–1751 · Jean-Pierre de Caussade, Letters on the Practice of Abandonment to Divine Providence 4.5

The way in which you keep in the presence of God by a simple glance of faith without mental images, figures, or any kind of representation, in a total surrender of your whole self, is the most pure and most perfect way of treating with God. It is the true prayer of the heart, a quite interior prayer, the sincere prayer of spirit to spirit, and the more simple, free, imperceptible, and removed it is, from all that can be felt so much the more solid, sublime, penetrating and efficacious it becomes, says the holy Mother de Chantal.

Methods and views

11 passages · 9 writers · 1200s to 1900s

Ignatius describes a method of prayer in which the person considers each word of the Our Father for as long as he finds meanings and consolation. Catherine of Siena says the soul should not abandon vocal prayer while imperfect but advance by degrees to mental prayer, and should leave vocal prayer when she feels her mind drawn by God's visitation. De Sales says to let the mind fall into mental prayer if drawn to it while saying vocal prayers, and Scougal calls mental prayer the great secret of devotion but says he does not recommend it so as to supersede the other sort. Bonaventure describes contemplating God outside us, within us, and above us as degrees of contemplation. Owen says that for contemplative prayer as described by the author he answers and others there is no precept, direction, motive, or example in Scripture, and objects that it leaves out Christ's mediation.

1370 · Catherine of Siena, The Dialogue (abridged, translated by Algar Thorold) 3.2

And when they have once completed their appointed tale, they do not appear to think of anything further, but seem to place devout attention and love in merely vocal recitation, which the soul is not required to do, for, in doing only this, she bears but little fruit, which pleases Me but little. But if you ask Me, whether the soul should abandon vocal prayer, since it does not seem to all that they are called to mental prayer, I should reply ’No.’ The soul should advance by degrees, and I know well that, just as the soul is at first imperfect and afterwards perfect, so also is it with her prayer. She should nevertheless continue in vocal prayer, while she is yet imperfect, so as not to fall into idleness. But she should not say her vocal prayers without joining them to mental prayer, that is to say, that while she is reciting, she should endeavor to elevate her mind in My love, with the consideration of her own defects and of the Blood of My only-begotten Son, wherein she finds the breadth of My charity and the remission of her sins.

c. 1521–1548 · Ignatius of Loyola, The Spiritual Exercises methods.2

The Second Method of Prayer is that the person, kneeling or seated, according to the greater disposition in which he finds himself and as more devotion accompanies him, keeping the eyes closed or fixed on one place, without going wandering with them, says Father, and is on the consideration of this word as long as he finds meanings, comparisons, relish and consolation in considerations pertaining to such word. And let him do in the same way on each word of the Our Father, or of any other prayer which he wants to say in this way.

1682 · John Owen, A Discourse of the Work of the Holy Spirit in Prayer 10

And in that exercise of these graces, wherein the life and being of prayer doth consist, a continual regard is to be had unto the mediation of Christ and the free promises of God; through which means he exhibits himself unto us as a God hearing prayer. These things are both plainly and frequently mentioned in the Scripture, as they are all of them exemplified in the prayers of those holy persons which are recorded therein. But for this contemplative prayer, as it is described by our author and others, there is neither precept for it, nor direction about it, nor motive unto it, nor example of it, in the whole Scripture. And it cannot but seem marvellous, to some at least, that whereas this duty and all its concernments are more insisted on therein than any other Christian duty or privilege whatever, the height and excellency of it, — and that in comparison whereof all other kinds of prayer, all the actings of the mind and soul in them, are decried, — should not obtain the least intimation therein. For if we should take a view of all the particular places wherein the nature and excellency of this duty are described, with the grace and privilege wherewith it is accompanied, — such as, for instance, Eph. vi. 18, Phil. iv. 6, Heb. iv. 16, x. 19–22, — there is nothing that is consistent with this contemplative prayer. Neither is there in the prayers of our Lord Jesus Christ, nor of his apostles, nor of any holy men from the beginning of the world, either for themselves or the whole church, any thing that gives the least countenance unto it.