The Monastic Pint Answers from church history on today's questions

Sola scriptura: Scripture alone

What Christian writers said, from about AD 174 to 1911.

51 passages · 34 writers · 7 centuries

The short answer

The Baptist, French, and Belgic confessions and the Thirty-Nine Articles hold that Scripture contains what is necessary for salvation and that nothing may be added to it or required beyond it, and Hodge and Ryle call the Bible the rule of faith and practice. Hodge, Owen, and Fausset hold that unwritten tradition is not a supplement to Scripture, Bullinger rejects traditions that disagree with it, and Watson and Calvin argue that Scripture does not receive its authority from the church. The Council of Trent says that truth and discipline are contained in the written books and the unwritten traditions, the First Vatican Council says that revelation is contained in the written books and unwritten traditions, and Trent says it belongs to the Church to judge the true sense of the Scriptures. The Orthodox Longer Catechism says tradition is needed as a guide to the right understanding of holy Scripture. Hippolytus says the knowledge of God is gained from the Holy Scriptures and from no other source, and Cyril of Jerusalem says the articles of the Faith are collected out of all the Scripture.

Scripture as the rule of faith

20 passages · 14 writers · 1500s to 1900s

Matthew Henry, Ryle, and Whitefield call Scripture the rule of faith and practice, and the Baptist Confession calls it the only sufficient, certain, and infallible rule of all saving knowledge, faith, and obedience. The Westminster Confession names the Holy Spirit speaking in the Scripture as the supreme judge of controversies of religion, and Spurgeon says the Word of God is the only tribunal to which we can go.

1571 · Church of England, The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion 6

Holy Scripture containeth all things necessary to salvation: so that whatsoever is not read therein, nor may be proved thereby, is not to be required of any man, that it should be believed as an article of the Faith, or be thought requisite or necessary to salvation.

1677 · Particular Baptist elders and congregations of London, The Baptist Confession of 1689 (the Second London Confession) 1.1

The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and infallible rule of all saving knowledge, faith, and obedience. Although the light of nature, and the works of creation and providence do so far manifest the goodness, wisdom, and power of God, as to leave men inexcusable; yet are they not sufficient to give that knowledge of God and his will which is necessary unto salvation. Therefore it pleased the Lord at sundry times and in divers manners to reveal himself, and to declare that his will unto his church; and afterward for the better preserving and propagating of the truth, and for the more sure establishment and comfort of the church against the corruption of the flesh, and the malice of Satan, and of the world, to commit the same wholly unto writing; which maketh the Holy Scriptures to be most necessary, those former ways of God's revealing his will unto his people being now ceased.

1856–1869 · J. C. Ryle, Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: Luke 10.25-28

Let the principle contained in these words, be one of the foundation principles of our Christianity. Let the Bible, the whole Bible, and nothing but the Bible, be the rule of our faith and practice. Holding this principle we travel upon the king's highway. The road may sometimes seem narrow, and our faith may be severely tried, but we shall not be allowed greatly to err.

Scripture, the church, and tradition: Protestant arguments

17 passages · 10 writers · 1500s to 1800s

Hodge, Owen, and Tillotson argue that unwritten traditions and the decrees of the Church are not a rule beside Scripture. Calvin and Watson argue that Scripture does not receive its authority from the church.

1559 · John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion 1.9.1

Those who, rejecting Scripture, imagine that they have some peculiar way of penetrating to God, are to be deemed not so much under the influence of error as madness. For certain giddy men have lately appeared, who, while they make a great display of the superiority of the Spirit, reject all reading of the Scriptures themselves, and deride the simplicity of those who only delight in what they call the dead and deadly letter. But I wish they would tell me what spirit it is whose inspiration raises them to such a sublime height that they dare despise the doctrine of Scripture as mean and childish. If they answer that it is the Spirit of Christ, their confidence is exceedingly ridiculous; since they will, I presume, admit that the apostles and other believers in the primitive Church were not illuminated by any other Spirit. None of these thereby learned to despise the word of God, but every one was imbued with greater reverence for it, as their writings most clearly testify.

1678 · John Owen, The Causes, Ways, and Means of Understanding the Mind of God 9

It is pleaded by some that the Scripture is to be interpreted according to catholic tradition, and no otherwise. And I do acknowledge that we should be inexpressibly obliged to them who would give us an interpretation of the whole Scripture, or of any book in the Scripture, or of any one passage in the Scripture, relating unto things of mere supernatural revelation, according unto that rule, or by the guidance and direction of it. But I fear no such tradition can be evidenced, unless it be of things manifest in the light of nature, whose universal preservation is an effect of the unavoidable reason of mankind, and not of any ecclesiastical tradition. Moreover, the Scripture itself is testified unto unanimously and uninterruptedly by all Christians to be the word of God; and hereby are all divine truths conveyed down from their original and delivered unto us. But a collateral tradition of any one truth or doctrine besides, from Christ and the apostles, cannot be proved; and if it could be so, it would be no means of the interpretation of the Scripture but only objectively, as one place of Scripture interprets another, — that is, it would belong unto the analogy of faith, contrary to which, or in opposition whereunto, no place ought to be interpreted. To pretend this, therefore, to be the rule of the interpretation of Scripture actively, as though thereby we could certainly learn the meaning of it, in part or in whole, is fond. Nor, whatever some do boast of, can any man living prove his interpretation of any one place to be dictated by or to be suitable unto universal tradition, any otherwise but as he can prove it to be agreeable to the Scripture itself; unless we shall acknowledge, without proof, that what is the mind and sense of some men who call themselves “The church” at present was the mind of Christ and his apostles, and of all true believers since, and that infallibly it is so.

1692 · Thomas Watson, A Body of Divinity, Contained in Sermons upon the Westminster Assembly's Catechism 2.2

The Papists cannot deny that the Scripture is divine and sacred; but they affirm quoad nos, with respect to us, it receives its divine authority from the church; and in proof of it they bring that Scripture, I Tim 3:15, where the church is said to be the ground and pillar of truth. It is true, the church is the pillar of truth; but it does not therefore follow that the Scripture has its authority from the church. The king's proclamation is fixed on the pillar, the pillar holds it out, that all may read, but the proclamation does not receive its authority from the pillar, but from the king; so the church holds forth the Scriptures, but they do not receive their authority from the church, but from God. If the Word of God be divine, merely because the church holds it forth, then it will follow, that our faith is to be built upon the church, and not upon the Word, contrary to Eph 2:20. ‘Built upon the foundation (that is the doctrine) of the apostles and prophets.'

1871 · Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, vol. 1 (Introduction; Part I, Theology Proper) intro.6.5

The Bible is a plain book. It is intelligible by the people. And they have the right, and are bound to read and interpret it for themselves; so that their faith may rest on the testimony of the Scriptures, and not on that of the Church. Such is the doctrine of Protestants on this subject. It is not denied that the Scriptures contain many things hard to be understood; that they require diligent study; that all men need the guidance of the Holy Spirit in order to right knowledge and true faith. But it is maintained that in all things necessary to salvation they are sufficiently plain to be understood even by the unlearned.

Catholic, Orthodox, and other statements on tradition

10 passages · 8 writers · 100s to 1800s

Trent receives the written books and the unwritten traditions with equal reverence, and the First Vatican Council says revelation is contained in the written books and unwritten traditions. The Orthodox Longer Catechism says tradition is needed as a guide to the right understanding of holy Scripture. Pusey says the Sixth Article does not address who interprets Scripture or the value of tradition in its interpretation, Barclay calls the Scriptures a secondary rule subordinate to the Spirit, Irenaeus reports that opponents object to the tradition that originates from the apostles, and Tertullian says the question to settle first is with whom lies the faith to which the Scriptures belong.

1546–1563 · Council of Trent, Canons and Dogmatic Decrees of the Council of Trent s4.canonical-scriptures

The sacred and holy, œcumenical, and general Synod of Trent,—lawfully assembled in the Holy Ghost, the same three legates of the Apostolic See presiding therein,—keeping this always in view, that, errors being removed, the purity itself of the Gospel be preserved in the Church; which (Gospel), before promised through the prophets in the holy Scriptures, our Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, first promulgated with His own mouth, and then commanded to be preached by His Apostles to every creature, as the fountain of all, both saving truth, and moral discipline; and seeing clearly that this truth and discipline are contained in the written books, and the unwritten traditions which, received by the Apostles from the mouth of Christ himself, or from the Apostles themselves, the Holy Ghost dictating, have come down even unto us, transmitted as it were from hand to hand: [the Synod] following the examples of the orthodox Fathers, receives and venerates with an equal affection of piety and reverence, all the books both of the Old and of the New Testament—seeing that one God is the author of both—as also the said traditions, as well those appertaining to faith as to morals, as having been dictated, either by Christ's own word of mouth, or by the Holy Ghost, and preserved in the Catholic Church by a continuous succession.

1546–1563 · Council of Trent, Canons and Dogmatic Decrees of the Council of Trent s4.edition-use

Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, it decrees, that no one, relying on his own skill, shall,—in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine,—wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,—whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures,—hath held and doth hold; or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such interpretations were never [intended] to be at any time published.

1830 · Philaret of Moscow, The Longer Catechism of the Orthodox, Catholic, Eastern Church intro.24

Why is tradition necessary even now? As a guide to the right understanding of holy Scripture, for the right ministration of the sacraments, and the preservation of sacred rites and ceremonies in the purity of their original institution. St. Basil the Great says of this as follows: Of the doctrines and injunctions kept by the Church, some we have from written instruction, but some we have received from apostolical tradition, by succession in private. Both the former and the latter have one and the same force for piety, and this will be contradicted by no one who has ever so little knowledge in the ordinances of the Church; for were we to dare to reject unwritten customs, as if they had no great importance, we should insensibly mutilate the Gospel, even in the most essential points, or, rather, for the teaching of the Apostles leave but an empty name.

Early writers on Scripture and the faith

4 passages · 3 writers · 100s to 300s

Hippolytus says the knowledge of God is gained from the Holy Scriptures and from no other source, and Cyril of Jerusalem says the articles of the Faith are collected out of all the Scripture and that the mysteries of the Faith must not be stated without the Holy Scriptures. Athanasius says the sacred and inspired Scriptures are sufficient to declare the truth.

c. 200–225 · Hippolytus of Rome, Against the Heresy of One Noetus (Contra Noetum) 9

There is, brethren, one God, the knowledge of whom we gain from the Holy Scriptures, and from no other source. For just as a man, if he wishes to be skilled in the wisdom of this world, will find himself unable to get at it in any other way than by mastering the dogmas of philosophers, so all of us who wish to practise piety will be unable to learn its practice from any other quarter than the oracles of God. Whatever things, then, the Holy Scriptures declare, at these let us look; and whatsoever things they teach, these let us learn; and as the Father wills our belief to be, let us believe; and as He wills the Son to be glorified, let us glorify Him; and as He wills the Holy Spirit to be bestowed, let us receive Him. Not according to our own will, nor according to our own mind, nor yet as using violently those things which are given by God, but even as He has chosen to teach them by the Holy Scriptures, so let us discern them.

c. 318–337 · Athanasius of Alexandria, Against the Heathen (Contra Gentes) 1.3

For although the sacred and inspired Scriptures are sufficient to declare the truth,—while there are other works of our blessed teachers compiled for this purpose, if he meet with which a man will gain some knowledge of the interpretation of the Scriptures, and be able to learn what he wishes to know,—still, as we have not at present in our hands the compositions of our teachers, we must communicate in writing to you what we learned from them,—the faith, namely, of Christ the Saviour; lest any should hold cheap the doctrine taught among us, or think faith in Christ unreasonable.

c. 348–351 · Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures (Catecheses ad illuminandos 1-18) 5.12

I wish you also to keep this as a provision through the whole course of your life, and beside this to receive no other, neither if we ourselves should change and contradict our present teaching, nor if an adverse angel, transformed into an angel of light should wish to lead you astray. For though we or an angel from heaven preach to you any other gospel than that ye have received, let him be to you anathema. So for the present listen while I simply say the Creed, and commit it to memory; but at the proper season expect the confirmation out of Holy Scripture of each part of the contents. For the articles of the Faith were not composed as seemed good to men; but the most important points collected out of all the Scripture make up one complete teaching of the Faith.

c. 348–351 · Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures (Catecheses ad illuminandos 1-18) 4.17

Have thou ever in thy mind this seal, which for the present has been lightly touched in my discourse, by way of summary, but shall be stated, should the Lord permit, to the best of my power with the proof from the Scriptures. For concerning the divine and holy mysteries of the Faith, not even a casual statement must be delivered without the Holy Scriptures; nor must we be drawn aside by mere plausibility and artifices of speech. Even to me, who tell thee these things, give not absolute credence, unless thou receive the proof of the things which I announce from the Divine Scriptures. For this salvation which we believe depends not on ingenious reasoning, but on demonstration of the Holy Scriptures.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.