The Monastic Pint Answers from church history on today's questions

Hebrews 11:6: without faith it is impossible to please God

What Christian writers said, from about AD 329 to 1929.

40 passages · 17 writers · 8 centuries

The short answer

Calvin says it is impossible to please God without faith because we all lie under his curse and have no remedy of our own, and Luther says work is worth nothing in dealings with God without faith. Barnes reads faith here as confidence in God's fidelity and promises, and Spurgeon says the man without faith puts a gross slight upon God and in effect denies his truthfulness. Wesley, Athanasius, and Spurgeon say that whoever comes to God must believe that he is. Chrysostom and Barnes say the believer must believe that God rewards those who seek him, and Calvin says the reward refers not to the worthiness or value of works but to faith. Owen says the faith of this verse is true, saving faith, not mere natural reason.

Why faith is required to please God

23 passages · 9 writers · 1200s to 1900s

Luther says that in dealings with God the work is worth nothing without faith, and Spurgeon says that without faith in any act, however religious, devout, and self-denying, it is impossible to please God. Barnes says faith here means confidence in God, and Calvin says this confidence rests on the grace of God alone and is fixed on Christ. Charnock says there is no true obedience before faith, and Calvin says we have no remedy in our own power.

1531 · Martin Luther, Commentary on the Epistle to the Galatians (abridged) 3

In our dealings with God the work is worth nothing without faith, for “without faith it is impossible to please him” (Hebrews 11:6). The sacrifice of Abel was better than the sacrifice of Cain, because Abel had faith. As to Cain he had no faith or trust in God’s grace, but strutted about in his own fancied worth.

1549 · John Calvin, Commentary on Hebrews 11.6

From these two clauses, we may learn how, and why it is impossible for man to please God without faith; God justly regards us all as objects of his displeasure, as we are all by nature under his curse; and we have no remedy in our own power. It is hence necessary that God should anticipate us by his grace; and hence it comes, that we are brought to know that God is, and in such a way that no corrupt superstition can seduce us, and also that we become assured of a certain salvation from him. Were any one to desire a fuller view of this subject, he should make his commencement here, — that we in vain attempt to try anything, except we look to God; for the only true end of life is to promote his glory; but this can never be done, unless there be first the true knowledge of him. Yet this is still but the half of faith, and will profit us but little, except confidence be added. Hence faith will only then be complete and secure us God’s favor, when we shall feel a confidence that we shall not seek him in vain, and thus entertain the certainty of obtaining salvation from him. But no one, except he be blinded by presumption, and fascinated by self-love, can feel assured that God will be a rewarder of his merits. Hence this confidence of which we speak recumbs not on works, nor on man’s own worthiness, but on the grace of God alone; and as grace is nowhere found but in Christ, it is on him alone that faith ought to be fixed.

1834 · Albert Barnes, Notes on the Bible: Hebrews 11.6

But without faith it is impossible to please him - Without "confidence" in God - in his fidelity, his truth, his wisdom, his promises. And this is as true in other things as in religion. It is impossible for a child to please his father unless he has confidence in him.

1877 · J. C. Ryle, Holiness: Its Nature, Hindrances, Difficulties, and Roots 10

That look was a little thing, but it told of proud unbelief in Lot’s wife. She seemed to doubt whether God was really going to destroy Sodom: she appeared not to believe there was any danger, or any need for such hasty flight. But without faith it is impossible to please God. (Heb. xi. 6.) The moment a man begins to think he knows better than God, and that God does not mean anything when He threatens, his soul is in great danger. When we cannot see the reason of God’s dealings, our duty is to hold our peace and believe.

He that cometh to God must believe that he is

11 passages · 9 writers · 300s to 1900s

Wesley says that to come to God in prayer or another act of worship one must believe that he is, and Athanasius says one must first believe that he is. Spurgeon says those who come to God must accept him as he reveals himself in the Scriptures and in Christ Jesus. Tillotson says there would be no religion without belief that God is, and Calvin says all are prohibited from access to God who do not distinguish him from all idols.

329–373 · Athanasius of Alexandria, Festal Letters 7.7

To this end He continually nourished His believing disciples with His words, and gave them life by the nearness of His divinity, but to the Canaanitish woman, because she was not yet a believer, He deigned not even a reply, although she stood greatly in need of food from Him. He did this not from scorn, far from it (for the Lord is loving to men and good, and on that account He went into the coasts of Tyre and Sidon); but because of her unbelief, and because she was of those who had not the word. And He did it righteously, my brethren; for there would have been nothing gained by her offering her supplication before believing, but by her faith she would support her petition; ‘For He that cometh to God, must first believe that He is, and that He is a rewarder of them that seek Him;’ and that ‘without faith it is impossible for a man to please Him.’

1820 · John Tillotson, Works, Volume 9 218

Now, that coming to God, and seeking him, are of the same importance here with pleasing him, will be clear to any that consider the apostle’s reasoning here in the text, which supposeth those to be the same, otherwise there would be no force in his argument. For the proposition which he proves, is, that “Without faith it is impossible to please God.” The argument he useth is this, “If every one that comes to God must believe that he is,” &c. then “without faith it is impossible to please him;” but “every one that comes to God must believe that he is.” Now, unless coming to God, and seeking him, be the same thing with pleasing him, this would be no good argument; for there would be four terms in it; but if these phrases be made equivalent, then the argument is good. Thus, if “every one that comes to God,” that is, that will please him, “must believe that he is,” &c. then “without faith it is impossible to please him:” but “every one that comes to God,” that is, that will please him, “must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him,” or that endeavour to please him; therefore “without faith it is impossible to please him.”

1901 · Charles Haddon Spurgeon, Spurgeon's Sermons, Volume 47 (1901) 2740

How is it possible for a man to come to One whose very existence he doubts? That matter must be settled or there cannot be any real coming to God. More than that, he that would come to God must believe that there is but one God—that the God of Abraham, of Isaac and of Jacob is the only living and true God. If we are to come to God—to the God of the Old and the New Testament—we must accept Him as He is there pleased to reveal Himself. We must not try to fashion a god such as we would like to have, for that would be idolatry—but we must accept God as He is made known in the Scriptures— and especially as He has manifested Himself in Christ Jesus, for it is in Him that God has revealed Himself to us for the practical purpose of our reconciliation. If we really wish to come to God it must be by the way in which He has come to us—that is, through His Son, Jesus Christ. Neither, let me add, shall we ever come to God aright unless we ask for the assistance of the Holy Spirit, the third Person of the blessed Trinity in Unity.

A rewarder of them that diligently seek him

6 passages · 5 writers · 400s to 1800s

Chrysostom says that if a man believes there is a God and a retribution, he will have the reward, and Barnes says it is impossible to make an acceptable approach to God without belief that he rewards those who seek him. Spurgeon says we must believe that God rewards the man who seeks him, and that the reward is on the ground of grace, not merit. Calvin says the reward refers not to the worthiness or value of works but to faith.

c. 403–404 · John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Epistle to the Hebrews 22.4

How was it “by faith” that “Enoch was translated”? Because his pleasing [God] was the cause of his translation, and faith [the cause] of his pleasing [Him]. For if he had not known that he should receive a reward, how could he have pleased [Him]? “But without faith it is impossible to please” Him. How? If a man believe that there is a God and a retribution, he will have the reward.

1549 · John Calvin, Commentary on Hebrews 11.6

And they reason thus: “We please God by faith, because we believe him to be a rewarder; then faith has respect to the merits of works.” This error cannot be better exposed, than by considering how God is to be sought; while any one is wandering from the right way of seeking him, he cannot be said to be engaged in the work. Now Scripture assigns this as the right way, — that a man, prostrate in himself, and smitten with the conviction that he deserves eternal death, and in self-despair, is to flee to Christ as the only asylum for salvation. Nowhere certainly can we find that we are to bring to God any merits of works to put us in a state of favor with him. Then he who understands that this is the only right way of seeking God, will be freed from every difficulty on the subject; for reward refers not to the worthiness or value of works but to faith. Thus, these frigid glosses of the Sophists, such as, “by faith we please God, for we deserve when we intend to please,” fall wholly to the ground. The Apostle’s object was to carry us much higher, even that conscience might feel assured that it is not a vain thing to seek God; and this certainty or assurance far exceeds what we can of ourselves attain, especially when any one considers his own self. For it is not to be laid down as an abstract principle, that God is a rewarder to those who seek him; but every one of us ought individually to apply this doctrine to himself, so that we may know that we are regarded by God, that he has such a care for our salvation as never to be wanting to us, that our prayers are heard by him, that he will be to us a perpetual deliverer.

1834 · Albert Barnes, Notes on the Bible: Hebrews 11.6

And that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him - This is equally necessary as the belief that he exists. If we could not believe that God would hear and answer our prayers, there could be no encouragement to call upon him. It is not meant here that the desire of the reward is to be the motive for seeking God - for the apostle makes no affirmation on that point; but that it is impossible to make an acceptable approach to him unless we have this belief.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.