The Monastic Pint Answers from church history on today's questions

What is holiness?

What Christian writers said, from about AD 370 to 1949.

54 passages · 30 writers · 6 centuries

The short answer

Charnock says God's holiness is a perfect freedom from all evil and that only he is absolutely holy, Watson says it consists in his perfect love of righteousness and abhorrence of evil, Tillotson says it is the perfection of all his other perfections, and Berkhof says his ethical holiness is separation from moral evil. Maclaren says the root idea of holiness is separation to God, with moral excellence the result of devotion to God, Bushnell says the original word means separation, being drawn apart by being consecrated to God, and Berkhof says holiness is always expressive of a relation to God. Watson says our holiness consists in suitableness to the nature of God and subjection to his will, Wesley and Owen describe it as conformity of our will to God's will and the renewal of the soul in his image, and Calvin says we are renewed in Christ to bear the image of God in knowledge, purity, righteousness, and true holiness. On the command to be holy as God is holy, Calvin says we ought to advance in this direction as far as our condition will bear, Barnes says the model for believers' lives is the character of the God who called them, and Fausset says God is essentially holy and gives the power to obey through the Spirit. Ryle calls holiness the habit of being of one mind with God, Manning says it consists in fulfilling the duties of our state in life and in spiritual fellowship with God, and Spurgeon says holiness minds its work at home and that morality is a clean outside while holiness is being clean within.

God's holiness

16 passages · 10 writers · 1600s to 1900s

Charnock says God's holiness negatively is a perfect and unpolluted freedom from all evil, and positively the rectitude of the divine nature, its conformity to the divine will. He also says holiness is a glorious perfection belonging to the nature of God, that purity is the splendor of every attribute in the Godhead, and that God alone is absolutely holy, creatures being holy by derivation from him. He says holiness is a perfection absolutely considered in the nature of God and righteousness a perfection as referred to others, and that the highest created purity is impurity beside God. Watson says God's holiness consists in his perfect love of righteousness and abhorrence of evil. Tillotson says God's holiness is not a particular but a universal perfection that runs through all his moral perfections, the beauty of the divine nature and the perfection of all his other perfections. Berkhof says holiness applies first to God, that its fundamental idea is unapproachableness based on God's distinctness from the creature, and that the ethical holiness of God is a separation from moral evil that abhors sin and demands purity in his moral creatures. Wesley says holy and holiness mean the same as God and Godhead, and that holiness is covered glory. Finney says holiness in God is that quality of his love that secures its conformity, in all its efforts and manifestations, to the divine idea of right. Henry says it is a matter of joy to the saints that God is a holy God, for then they hope he will make them holy.

1675–1680 · Stephen Charnock, Discourses upon the Existence and Attributes of God 11

The holiness of God negatively, is a perfect and unpolluted freedom from all evil. As we call gold pure that is not embased by any dross, and that garment clean that is free from any spot, so the nature of God is estranged from all shadow of evil, all imaginable contagion. Positively, It is the rectitude or integrity of the Divine nature, or that conformity of it, in affection and action, to the Divine will, as to his eternal law, whereby he works with a becomingness to his own excellency, and whereby he hath a delight and complacency in everything agreeable to his will, and an abhorrency of everything contrary thereunto.

1675–1680 · Stephen Charnock, Discourses upon the Existence and Attributes of God 11

Holiness is a glorious perfection belonging to the nature of God. Hence he is in Scripture styled often the Holy One, the Holy One of Jacob, the Holy One of Israel; and oftener entitled Holy, than Almighty, and set forth by this part of his dignity more than by any other. This is more affixed as an epithet to his name than any other: you never find it expressed, His mighty name, or His wise name; but His great name, and most of all, His holy name. This is his greatest title of honor; in this doth the majesty and venerableness of his name appear. When the sinfulness of Sennacherib is aggravated, the Holy Ghost takes the rise from this attribute (2 Kings xix. 22). “Thou hast lift up thine eyes on high, even against the Holy One of Israel;” not against the wise, mighty, &c., but against the Holy One of Israel, as that wherein the majesty of God was most illustrious. It is upon this account he is called light, as impurity is called darkness; both in this sense are opposed to one another: he is a pure and unmixed light, free from all blemish in his essence, nature, and operations.

1949 · Louis Berkhof, Systematic Theology 1.1.7

The fundamental idea of the ethical holiness of God is also that of separation, but in this case it is a separation from moral evil or sin. In virtue of His holiness God can have no communion with sin, Job 34:10; Hab. 1:13. Used in this sense, the word "holiness" points to God's majestic purity, or ethical majesty. But the idea of ethical holiness is not merely negative (separation from sin); it also has a positive content, namely, that of moral excellence, or ethical perfection. If man reacts to God's majestic-holiness with a feeling of utter insignificance and awe, his reaction to the ethical holiness reveals itself in a sense of impurity, a consciousness of sin, Isa. 6:5. Otto also recognizes this element in the holiness of God, though he stresses the other, and says of the response to it: "Mere awe, mere need of shelter from the 'tremendum', has here been elevated to the feeling that man in his 'profaneness' is not worthy to stand in the presence of the Holy One, and that his entire personal unworthiness might defile even holiness itself." This ethical holiness of God may be defined as that perfection of God, in virtue of which He eternally wills and maintains His own moral excellence, abhors sin, and demands purity in his moral creatures.

Holiness as separation to God

10 passages · 8 writers · 300s to 1900s

Maclaren says the root meaning of holiness is separated, set apart to God, that it expresses primarily relation to God and not moral character, and that holiness as moral excellence is the result of holiness as devotion to God. Bushnell says the original word means separation, the character of being drawn apart by being consecrated to God. Berkhof says the idea of holiness is never that of moral goodness considered in itself, but always that of ethical goodness seen in relation to God. Spurgeon says the way of holiness is dedication of ourselves to God without reserve, to which conformity to the will and character of God must be added, and that the restored nature is to be wholly consecrated to God. Tillotson says things are called holy when separated from common use and appropriated to the service of God, and that in good men holiness is a separation from sin and moral imperfection. Murray says holiness is the filling with that which is good, with the disposition of Jesus, and that Christ's life in us is our holiness. Jerome says it is a scriptural usage to give the name of holy to those who are clean or have been purified.

c. 370–419 · Jerome, Letters 85.5

Consider also that the vessels of which we read in the tabernacle are called holy and everything else required for the ceremonial worship: although in strictness of speech there can be nothing holy except creatures which know of and worship God. But it is a scriptural usage sometimes to give the name of holy to those who are clean, or who have been purified, or who have made expiation. For instance, it is written of Bathsheba that she was made holy from her uncleanness, and the temple itself is called the holy place.

1907 · Alexander Maclaren, Expositions of Holy Scripture: Exodus 28.36

And what is it? It is a very unfortunate thing—indicating superficiality of thought—that the modern popular notion of ‘holiness’ identifies it with purity, righteousness, moral perfection. Now that idea is in it, but is not the whole of it. For, not to spend time upon mere remarks on words, the meaning of the word thus rendered is in Hebrew, as well as in Greek and in our own English, one and the same. The root-meaning is ‘separated,’ ‘set apart,’ and the word expresses primarily, not moral character, but relation to God. That makes all the difference; and it incalculably deepens the conception, as well as puts us on the right track for understanding the only possible means by which there can ever be realised that moral perfection and excellence which has unfortunately monopolised the meaning of the word in most people’s minds. The first thought is ‘set apart to God.’ That is holiness, in its root and germ.

1908–1909 · Alexander Maclaren, Expositions of Holy Scripture: Psalms 51.10-12

Holiness considered as moral excellence is the result of holiness considered as devotion to God. And learn too that holiness in both aspects comes from the operation and indwelling in our spirits of a divine Spirit, who draws away our love from self to fix it on Him, which changes our blindness into sight, and makes us by degrees like Himself, ‘holy, harmless, undefiled, separate from sinners.’

The holiness required of his people

19 passages · 11 writers · 1500s to 1800s

Watson says our holiness consists in our suitableness to the nature of God and our subjection to his will, God's nature being the pattern of holiness and his will its rule. Wesley says holiness is the renewal of the soul in the image of God, and that conformity of our will and affections to God's will is properly holiness. Wesley also says the petition "Cleanse the thoughts of our hearts" contains the negative branch of inward holiness, purity of heart, and "that we may perfectly love thee" the positive part. Owen says holiness is the universal correspondence of our natures and actions to the will of God, resting on the universal renovation of our natures into the image of God, and that all holiness consists in conformity and obedience to God's revealed will. Calvin says we are renewed in Christ to bear the image of God in knowledge, purity, righteousness, and true holiness, and Barnes says the object of redemption is to restore to man the lost image of God. Edwards says the grace in the hearts of the saints is of the same nature as the divine holiness, though infinitely less in degree. Watson says God predestinates us to Christ's image, which consists in righteousness and true holiness. On "Be ye holy, for I am holy," Calvin says God, as the fountain of all holiness, makes holy wherever he comes, and that in bidding us be holy like himself we ought to advance as far as our condition will bear. Barnes says the model for believers' lives is the character of the God who called them, and Fausset says God is essentially holy and gives the power to obey through the sanctifying of the Spirit. Owen says goodness, kindness, and love is the grace of holiness that represents the nature of God.

1559 · John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion 1.15.4

To the same effect Paul elsewhere says, that beholding the glory of Christ with unveiled face, we are transformed into the same image. We now see how Christ is the most perfect image of God, into which we are so renewed as to bear the image of God in knowledge, purity, righteousness, and true holiness.

1692 · Thomas Watson, A Body of Divinity, Contained in Sermons upon the Westminster Assembly's Catechism 3.7

Our holiness consists in our suitableness to the nature of God. Hence the saints are said to partake of the divine nature, which is not partaking of his essence, but his image. 2 Pet 1:1. Herein is the saints' holiness, when they are the lively pictures of God. They bear the image of God's meekness, mercifulness, heavenliness; they are of the same judgement with God, of the same disposition; they love what he loves, and hate what he hates. Our holiness consists also in our subjection to the will of God. As God's nature is the pattern of holiness, so his will is the rule of holiness.

1872 · John Wesley, Sermons on Several Occasions 120

What, then, is that holiness which is the true “wedding garment,” the only qualification for glory? “In Christ Jesus,” (that is, according to the Christian institution, whatever be the case of the heathen world,) “neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision; but a new creation, — the renewal of the soul “in the image of God wherein it was created.” In “Christ Jesus neither circumcision availeth anything, nor uncircumcision, but faith which worketh by love.” [Gal. 5:6] It first, through the energy of God, worketh love to God and all mankind; and, by this love, every holy and heavenly temper, — in particular, lowliness, meekness, gentleness, temperance, and longsuffering. “It is neither circumcision,” — the attending on all the Christian ordinances, — “nor uncircumcision,” — the fulfilling of all heathen morality, — but “the keeping the commandments of God; particularly those, — “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and thy neighbour as thyself.” In a word, holiness is the having “the mind that was in Christ,” and the “walking as Christ walked.”

Holiness of life

9 passages · 6 writers · 1700s to 1800s

Ryle says holiness is the habit of being of one mind with God, agreeing in his judgment, hating what he hates and loving what he loves. Manning says holiness consists in a due fulfilment of the relative duties of our state in life and in spiritual fellowship with God. Spurgeon says holiness has to do with the acts and thoughts of intelligent subjects, not with places or things, and that it minds its work at home as a kind father, a true brother, and an obedient child. He also says morality is a clean outside, but holiness is being clean within and hallowed unto God, and that holiness requires conformity to God's character, consecration to God, and close communion between the soul and God. Hodge says holiness implies entire freedom from moral evil and that to be holy is to be clean. Law says the holiness of the Christian life implies a dedication of ourselves to God that resembles the death of Christ, and a new life that shows we are risen with Christ.

1726 · William Law, A Practical Treatise upon Christian Perfection 2

This is the true undeniable state of Christianity; baptism does not make us effectually Christians, unless it brings us into a state of death, consecrates us to God, and begins a life suitable to that state of things to which our Saviour is risen from the dead. This, and no other than this, is the holiness and spiritual temper of the Christian life, which implies such a resignation of mind, such a dedication of ourselves to God, as may resemble the death of Christ. And on the other hand, such a newness of life, such an ascension of the soul, such a holy and heavenly behaviour, as may show that we are risen with Christ, and belong to that glorious state, where he now sits at the right hand of God. It is in this sense, that the holy Jesus saith of his disciples, they are not of this world, even as I am not of this world; being not left to live the life of the world, but chosen out of it for the purposes of his kingdom, that they might copy after his death, and oblation of himself to God. And this is the condition of all Christians to the consummation of all things, who are to carry on the same designs, and by the same means raise out of this corrupted state a number of fellow-heirs with Christ in everlasting glory.

1861 · Charles Haddon Spurgeon, Spurgeon's Sermons, Volume 7 (1861) 399

Some seem to think that there is some peculiar sanctity about aisles and oak seats, stone pillars and gothic arches. Holiness cannot belong to stones, holiness has to do with nothing except the acts and thoughts of intelligent subjects, and if holiness can by metaphor belong to places or substances, it must be through the Christian holy minds that are in contact with them. I will not have it that yonder parish church or that this place is one whit more holy than that room where you live if you there offer prayer and praise. Oh! brethren, you must not think that the table, and the font, and the baptistry are holy; no, no, if there be holiness in them so may there be in your own table, in your own labors, and in your own tools which you handle, at least, there will be as much in one as in the other if with a holy mind you serve God in both. Not confined holiness—that is superstition; universal holiness—that is Christianity, not the bowls upon the altar holy—that is Judaism, but the bells upon the horses holy—that is true living godliness and vital Christianity. See to it, then, Christian friends, in your common daily doings, that the bells upon the horses are Holiness unto the Lord.

1877 · J. C. Ryle, Holiness: Its Nature, Hindrances, Difficulties, and Roots 3

Holiness is the habit of being of one mind with God, according as we find His mind described in Scripture. It is the habit of agreeing in God’s judgment—hating what He hates—loving what He loves—and measuring everything in this world by the standard of His Word. He who most entirely agrees with God, he is the most holy man. (b) A holy man will endeavour to shun every known sin, and to keep every known commandment. He will have a decided bent of mind toward God, a hearty desire to do His will—a greater fear of displeasing Him than of displeasing the world, and a love to all His ways.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.