The Monastic Pint Answers from church history on today's questions

What is heaven?

What Christian writers said, from about AD 95 to 1938.

248 passages · 57 writers · 15 centuries

The short answer

The 248 passages here come from 57 writers between AD 95 and 1938: 132 state a view on heaven and 116 mention it in passing. Writers describe heaven as the sight and enjoyment of God, as the home and city of the redeemed, as an inheritance and a rest, and as joy and praise among the angels and saints. They differ on whether the dead are in heaven now or await the resurrection, whether the blessed share equal glory, and whether the final state is a renewed earth or a place above. Several writers say that heaven cannot be fully described, and some warn against speculation. Among the 132 statements, Philaret of Moscow is the only Orthodox writer after the church fathers, and Martin Luther is the only Lutheran.

Seeing and enjoying God

10 passages · 10 writers · 100s to 1900s

Writers describe heaven as the sight and enjoyment of God, and discuss what that sight is and how it is given.

180

If therefore, at the present time, having the earnest, we do cry, “Abba, Father,” what shall it be when, on rising again, we behold Him face to face; when all the members shall burst out into a continuous hymn of triumph, glorifying Him who raised them from the dead, and gave the gift of eternal life? For if the earnest, gathering man into itself, does even now cause him to cry, “Abba, Father,” what shall the complete grace of the Spirit effect, which shall be given to men by God? It will render us like unto Him, and accomplish the will of the Father; for it shall make man after the image and likeness of God.

Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies: Book V 9

1395

And then shall we see God face to face, homely and fully. The creature that is made shall see and endlessly behold God which is the Maker.

Julian of Norwich, Revelations of Divine Love 15.3

1904–1910

Let us be content to be ignorant, and believe with confidence that we shall find that the vision of God is the heaven of heavens. … We see God when we have God. When we have God we have enough.

Alexander Maclaren, Ezekiel, Daniel and the Minor Prophets; and Matthew Chaps. I to VIII 2.19

Who enters heaven

10 passages · 9 writers · 300s to 1900s

Writers say what is required of those who enter heaven, including holiness, grace, and union with Christ.

387

We are enrolled in heaven: our citizenship is there! … But that City above is not of this kind; for it is impossible that he can be a partaker of it, who has not exhibited every virtue.

John Chrysostom, The Homilies on the Statues to the People of Antioch 19

c. 440–461

Rightly is this blessedness promised to purity of heart. For the brightness of the true light will not be able to be seen by the unclean sight: and that which will be happiness to minds that are bright and clean, will be a punishment to those that are stained. Therefore, let the mists of earth’s vanities be shunned, and your inward eyes purged from all the filth of wickedness, that the sight may be free to feed on this great manifestation of God .

Leo the Great, The Letters and Sermons of Leo the Great 5.48

1674

All unholy persons, therefore, who feed and refresh themselves with hopes of heaven and eternity do it merely on false notions of God and blessedness, whereby they deceive themselves. Heaven is a place where as well they would not be as they cannot be; in itself it is neither desired by them nor fit for them.

John Owen, Pneumatologia 5.1

1692

There is no going to heaven without sanctification. … Heaven is not like Noah's ark, where the clean beasts and the unclean entered. … It must be a clear eye that sees a bright object: only a holy heart can see God in his glory.

Thomas Watson, A Body of Divinity 6.5

1834–1885

How blessed will be heaven, Co2 7:1. There we shall be perfect. And the crowning glory of heaven is not that we shall be happy, but that we shall be holy. Whatever there is in the heart that is good shall there be perfectly developed; whatever there is that is evil shall be removed, and the whole soul will be like God.

Albert Barnes, Notes on the Bible Second Corinthians 7:16

Bodies and the resurrection

10 passages · 10 writers · 100s to 1900s

Writers describe the condition of the risen body in heaven and how it relates to the soul and to the angels.

c. 197–220

“They shall be,” says He, “equal unto the angels.” As by not marrying, because of not dying, so, of course, by not having to yield to any like necessity of our bodily state; even as the angels, too, sometimes. were “equal unto” men, by eating and drinking, and submitting their feet to the washing of the bath—having clothed themselves in human guise, without the loss of their own intrinsic nature. If therefore angels, when they became as men, submitted in their own unaltered substance of spirit to be treated as if they were flesh, why shall not men in like manner, when they become “equal unto the angels,” undergo in their unchanged substance of flesh the treatment of spiritual beings, no more exposed to the usual solicitations of the flesh in their angelic garb, than were the angels once to those of the spirit when encompassed in human form?

Tertullian, On the Resurrection of the Flesh 62

c. 397–410

But the virtue of the resurrection confers on men an angelical state, so that they who have risen from the earth shall not live again on the earth with the brute animals but with angels in heaven—yet those only whose purer life has fitted them for this—those, namely, who even now preserving the flesh of their soul in chastity, have brought it into subjection to the Holy Spirit, and thus with every stain of sins done away and changed into spiritual glory by the virtue of sanctification, have been counted worthy to have it admitted into the society of angels.

Rufinus of Aquileia, Life and Works of Rufinus with Jerome's Apology Against Rufinus 13.42

1265–1274

I answer that, It is manifest that the happiness of the saints will increase in extent after the resurrection, because their happiness will then be not only in the soul but also in the body. Moreover, the soul's happiness also will increase in extent, seeing that the soul will rejoice not only in its own good, but also in that of the body.

Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica Suppl..Q93.A1

1378

And think not, that the bliss of the body after the resurrection gives more bliss to the soul, for, if this were so, it would follow that, until they had the body, they had imperfect bliss, which cannot be, because no perfection is lacking to them. So it is not the body that gives bliss to the soul, but the soul will give bliss to the body, because the soul will give of her abundance, and will re-clothe herself on the Last Day of Judgment, in the garments of her own flesh which she had quitted.

Catherine of Siena, The Dialogue 3.25

1839

Shall the body also share in the happiness of the soul? Yes; it too will be glorified with the light of God, as Christ's body was at his transfiguration on Mount Tabor. It is sown in dishonor, it is raised in glory. 1 Cor. xv. 43. As we have borne the image of the earthy, that is, of Adam, we shall also bear the image of the heavenly.

Philaret of Moscow, The Longer Catechism of the Orthodox, Catholic, Eastern Church q. 378–385

Heaven between death and the resurrection

8 passages · 7 writers · 200s to 1900s

Writers differ on whether the dead are in heaven now or await the resurrection, and on how complete their happiness is in the meantime.

c. 220–250

I think, therefore, that all the saints who depart from this life will remain in some place situated on the earth, which holy Scripture calls paradise, as in some place of instruction, and, so to speak, class-room or school of souls, in which they are to be instructed regarding all the things which they had seen on earth, and are to receive also some information respecting things that are to follow in the future, as even when in this life they had obtained in some degree indications of future events, although “through a glass darkly,” all of which are revealed more clearly and distinctly to the saints in their proper time and place. If any one indeed be pure in heart, and holy in mind, and more practised in perception, he will, by making more rapid progress, quickly ascend to a place in the air, and reach the kingdom of heaven, through those mansions, so to speak, in the various places which the Greeks have termed spheres, i.e., globes, but which holy Scripture has called heavens; in each of which he will first see clearly what is done there, and in the second place, will discover the reason why things are so done: and thus he will in order pass through all gradations, following Him who hath passed into the heavens, Jesus the Son of God, who said, “I will that where I am, these may be also.” And of this diversity of places He speaks, when He says, “In My Father’s house are many mansions.”

Origen of Alexandria, The Works of Origen 3.11

1559

And did not the soul, when unclothed from the body, retain its essence, and be capable of beatific glory, our Savior would not have said to the thief, “Today shalt thou be with me in paradise,” (Luke 23:43). … Many greatly torment themselves with discussing what place they occupy, and whether or not they already enjoy celestial glory. It is foolish and rash to inquire into hidden things, farther than God permits us to know.

John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion III.25

1714

Heaven is comfort, and hell is torment: heaven is joy, hell is weeping, and wailing, and pain in perfection. [2.] The soul, as soon as it leaves the body, goes either to heaven or hell, to comfort or torment, immediately, and does not sleep, or go into purgatory. … In heaven there is everlasting consolation.

Matthew Henry, Commentary on Luke 16.2

1839

The souls of the righteous are in light and rest, with a foretaste of eternal happiness; but the souls of the wicked are in a state the reverse of this.

Philaret of Moscow, The Longer Catechism of the Orthodox, Catholic, Eastern Church q. 366–373

1930–1933

Today shalt thou be with me in Paradise (Σημερον μετ' εμου εση εν τω παραδεισω). However crude may have been the robber's Messianic ideas Jesus clears the path for him. He promises him immediate and conscious fellowship after death with Christ in Paradise which is a Persian word and is used here not for any supposed intermediate state; but the very bliss of heaven itself. This Persian word was used for an enclosed park or pleasure ground (so Xenophon). The word occurs in two other passages in the N.T. (2Co 12:4; Re 2:7 ), in both of which the reference is plainly to heaven.

A.T. Robertson, Word Pictures in the New Testament 4.23

New heavens and a new earth

8 passages · 8 writers · 100s to 1900s

Writers discuss whether the final state is a renewed creation, how it relates to the present world, and how it relates to a millennium.

180

For neither is the substance nor the essence of the creation annihilated (for faithful and true is He who has established it), but “the fashion of the world passeth away;” that is, those things among which transgression has occurred, since man has grown old in them. And therefore this [present] fashion has been formed temporary, God foreknowing all things; as I have pointed out in the preceding book, and have also shown, as far as was possible, the cause of the creation of this world of temporal things. But when this [present] fashion [of things] passes away, and man has been renewed, and flourishes in an incorruptible state, so as to preclude the possibility of becoming old, [then] there shall be the new heaven and the new earth, in which the new man shall remain [continually], always holding fresh converse with God.

Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies: Book V 37

c. 303–313

But when the thousand years shall be completed, the world shall be renewed by God, and the heavens shall be folded together, and the earth shall be changed, and God shall transform men into the similitude of angels, and they shall be white as snow; and they shall always be employed in the sight of the Almighty, and shall make offerings to their Lord, and serve Him for ever.

Lactantius, The Divine Institutes 7.26

c. 362–389

I await the voice of the Archangel, the last trumpet, the transformation of the heavens, the transfiguration of the earth, the liberation of the elements, the renovation of the universe. Then shall I see Cæsarius himself, no longer in exile, no longer laid upon a bier, no longer the object of mourning and pity, but brilliant, glorious, heavenly, such as in my dreams I have often beheld thee, dearest and most loving of brothers, pictured thus by my desire, if not by the very truth.

Gregory of Nazianzus, Select Orations of Saint Gregory Nazianzen 6

1873

This earth, according to the common opinion, that is, this renovated earth, is to be the final seat of Christ’s kingdom. This is the new heavens; this is the New Jerusalem, the Mount Zion in which are to be gathered the general assembly and church of the first-born, which are written in heaven; the spirits of just men made perfect; this is the heavenly Jerusalem; the city of the living God; the kingdom prepared for his people before the foundation of the world.

Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology IV.4.3

The heavenly city and the New Jerusalem

9 passages · 7 writers · 300s to 1800s

Writers read the heavenly Jerusalem as the church, as a real city, or as a picture of the final state.

312–325

But the region above the heavens, with the models of earthly things which are there, and the so-called Jerusalem above, and the heavenly Mount of Zion, and the supramundane city of the living God, in which innumerable choirs of angels and the Church of the first born, whose names are written in heaven, praise their Maker and the Supreme Ruler of the universe with hymns of praise unutterable and incomprehensible to us,—who that is mortal is able worthily to celebrate this? ‘For eye hath not seen nor ear heard, neither have entered into the heart of men those things which God hath prepared for them that love him.’

Eusebius of Caesarea, The Church History of Eusebius 10.4

1418–1427

O MOST happy mansion of the city above! … It envelops the saints all resplendent with heavenly brightness, but it appears far off as through a glass to us wanderers on the earth. The citizens of heaven know how joyful that day is, but the exiled sons of Eve mourn that this one is bitter and tedious.

Thomas à Kempis, The Imitation of Christ 3.48

1725

The temple of the new Jerusalem, which was no material temple, made with men's hands, as that of Solomon and Zerubbabel, but a temple altogether spiritual and divine; for the Lord God Almighty, and the Lamb, are the temple thereof. There the saints are above the need of ordinances, which were the means of their preparation for heaven. When the end is attained the means are no longer useful. Perfect and immediate communion with God will more than supply the place of gospel institutions.

Matthew Henry, Commentary on Revelation 21.2

Differences of reward and glory

9 passages · 8 writers · 1st c. to 1800s

Writers ask whether the blessed share equal or unequal glory, and how reward relates to works and grace.

c. 95–110

As the presbyters say, then those who are deemed worthy of an abode in heaven shall go there, others shall enjoy the delights of Paradise, and others shall possess the splendour of the city; for everywhere the Saviour will be seen, according as they shall be worthy who see Him. But that there is this distinction between the habitation of those who produce an hundred-fold, and that of those who produce sixty-fold, and that of those who produce thirty-fold; for the first will be taken up into the heavens, the second class will dwell in Paradise, and the last will inhabit the city

Papias of Hierapolis, Fragments of Papias 2.5

375

For among the glories of the saints are “many mansions” in the Father’s house, that is differences of dignities: for as “star differeth from star in glory, so also is the resurrection of the dead.” They, then, that were sealed by the Spirit unto the day of redemption, and preserve pure and undiminished the first fruits which they received of the Spirit, are they that shall hear the words “well done thou good and faithful servant; thou hast been faithful over a few things, I will make thee ruler over many things.”

Basil of Caesarea, De Spiritu Sancto 17

1395

For right as to every sin is answering a pain by truth, right so for every sin, to the same soul is given a bliss by love: right as diverse sins are punished with diverse pains according as they be grievous, right so shall they be rewarded with diverse joys in Heaven according as they have been painful and sorrowful to the soul in earth. For the soul that shall come to Heaven is precious to God, and the place so worshipful that the goodness of God suffereth never that soul to sin that shall come there without that the which sin shall be rewarded; and it is made known without end, and blissfully restored by overpassing worship.

Julian of Norwich, Revelations of Divine Love 14.12

1755–1765

There is an inconceivable variety in the degrees of reward in the other world. … The difference between the very highest and the lowest state in the world is nothing to the smallest difference between the degrees of glory. But who has time to think of this? Who is at all concerned about it? Standing before the throne - In the full vision of God.

John Wesley, Notes on the Bible 27.7

1858

Our title to heaven is all of grace. Our degree of glory in heaven will be in proportion to our deeds. Every person will receive his own reward according to his own labor.

J.C. Ryle, Expository Thoughts on Luke 19:11-27

Heaven as a place, a home, and the Father's house

10 passages · 9 writers · 100s to 1900s

Writers describe where heaven is and what kind of place it is, including the mansions of John 14 and the presence of Christ.

c. 386–430

If, my brethren, we understand by heaven the firmament which we see with our bodily eyes, we shall indeed so err, as to imagine that we cannot ascend thither without ladders, or some scaling machines: but if we ascend spiritually, we ought to understand heaven spiritually: if the ascent be in affection, heaven is in righteousness. What is then the heaven of God? All holy souls, all righteous souls. … But they are already heaven in whom God already dwelleth visibly, who see Him face to face; all the holy Apostles, all the holy Virtues, Powers, Thrones, Lordships, that heavenly Jerusalem, wanderers from whence we groan, and for which we pray with longing; and there God dwelleth.

Augustine of Hippo, Expositions on the Book of Psalms 123

1265–1274

The empyrean heaven rests only on the authority of Strabus and Bede, and also of Basil; all of whom agree in one respect, namely, in holding it to be the place of the blessed. Strabus and Bede say that as soon as created it was filled with angels; and Basil [*Hom. ii. in Hexaem.] says: "Just as the lost are driven into the lowest darkness, so the reward for worthy deeds is laid up in the light beyond this world, where the just shall obtain the abode of rest."

Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica I.Q66.A3

1904–1910

I believe that heaven is a place. … I believe that that involves locality, circumstance, external occupations; and I say, all that being so, and in its own place very important, yet if we stop there, we have no vision of the real light that makes the lustre, no true idea of the glory that makes the blessedness.

Alexander Maclaren, Matthew IX to XVIII 2.7

The saints and angels in heaven

10 passages · 9 writers · 300s to 1900s

Writers describe the company of heaven, how the blessed know and regard one another, and their likeness to the angels.

1609

Consider the beauty and perfection of the countless inhabitants of that blessed country;—the millions and millions of angels, Cherubim and Seraphim; the glorious company of Apostles, martyrs, confessors, virgins, and saints. O blessed company, any one single member of which surpasses all the glory of this world, what will it be to behold them all, to sing with them the sweet Song of the Lamb? They rejoice with a perpetual joy, they share a bliss unspeakable, and unchangeable delights.

Francis de Sales, Introduction to the Devout Life 1.16

1692

We shall not only know our friends and godly relations, but those glorified saints whom we never saw before. It must be so; for society without acquaintance is not comfortable. Of this opinion were Augustine, Anselm, and Luther. Indeed, the Scripture seems to hint as much to us; for, if Peter in the transfiguration knew Moses and Elias, whom he never saw before, Matt 17: 3, then surely in heaven the saints shall know one another, and be infinitely delighted in each other's company.

Thomas Watson, A Body of Divinity 7.2

1758

We know that all the happiness of the saints in heaven is entirely dependent on those great things that Christ did on earth, in the work of redemption, as it was purchased by it; and there is reason to think that their knowledge and glory is in other respects, by what they see of these great works of providence which God carries on in the world in the prosecution of the grand design of redemption.

Jonathan Edwards, Notes on the Bible 13

1883

Nay, and we shall also recognise each other, not only by the fellowship of the soul; but as, even now, the mind impresses its stamp on the features, so then, when all shall be quite true, shall the soul, so to speak, body itself forth, fully impress itself on the outward appearance, and for the first time shall we then fully recognise those whom we shall now fully know - with all of earth that was in them left behind, and all of God and good fully developed and ripened into perfectness of beauty.

Alfred Edersheim, The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah 5.4

Joy, praise, and rest

10 passages · 8 writers · 100s to 1800s

Writers describe what the blessed do and experience in heaven, including joy, worship, rest, service, and the absence of sorrow.

c. 180–185

To those who by patient continuance in well-doing seek immortality, He will give life everlasting, joy, peace, rest, and abundance of good things, which neither hath eye seen, nor ear heard, nor hath it entered into the heart of man to conceive.

Theophilus of Antioch, Theophilus to Autolycus - Book I 14

1070–1109

There is no assailing foe, nor no wantonness of sin there. There is no want there, no uncomeliness, no strife, no insolence, no wrangling, no fear, no uneasiness, no pain, no doubt, no violence, no discord; but peace profound, and perfect love, and jubilation, and eternal praise of God, and unanxious rest for ever, and joy in the Holy Ghost for evermore. O, how blessed shall I be if I hear those Thy people’s jocund melodies, and their sweet hymns pouring forth with due honour praises to the most high Trinity!

Anselm of Canterbury, Meditations and Prayers 2.14

1126–1141

In these earthly dwellings, though men may rejoice, yet they have still other battles to fight, other mortal perils to undergo. But in the heavenly Fatherland no sorrow nor sadness can enter: as it is written, ‘The habitation of all rejoicing ones is in Thee’ (Ps. 87. 7, Vulg.); and again, ‘Everlasting joy shall be unto them’ (Isa. 61.7). Nor could they recall things piteous, for then they will make mention of God’s righteousness only.

Bernard of Clairvaux, On Loving God 15

1877

The praise of the Lord Jesus will be the eternal song of all the inhabitants of heaven. … The service of the Lord Jesus will be one eternal occupation of all the inhabitants of heaven. We shall “serve Him day and night in His temple.” (Rev. vii. 13.) Blessed is the thought that we shall at length attend on Him without distraction, and work for Him without weariness.

J.C. Ryle, Holiness 21

A lasting inheritance

28 passages · 18 writers · 100s to 1900s

Writers describe heaven as an inheritance that is eternal, secure, and unchanging.

375

Through the Holy Spirit comes our restoration to paradise, our ascension into the kingdom of heaven, our return to the adoption of sons, our liberty to call God our Father, our being made partakers of the grace of Christ, our being called children of light, our sharing in eternal glory, and, in a word, our being brought into a state of all “fulness of blessing,” both in this world and in the world to come, of all the good gifts that are in store for us, by promise hereof, through faith, beholding the reflection of their grace as though they were already present, we await the full enjoyment. If such is the earnest, what the perfection? If such the first fruits, what the complete fulfilment?

Basil of Caesarea, De Spiritu Sancto 16

1535

As the children of God we are the heirs of His eternal heaven. What a wonderful gift heaven is, man’s heart cannot conceive, much less describe. Until we enter upon our heavenly inheritance we are only to have our little faith to go by.

Martin Luther, Commentary on Galatians 4:7

1692

Christ has not only redeemed us out of prison, but he has redeemed us to a state of happiness, to an inheritance; heaven is not a lease which soon expires, but an inheritance; and a glorious inheritance; called an inheritance in light. Col 1:12. Lumen producit colores; light adorns and gilds the world. What were the world without light but a prison? The heavenly inheritance is irradiated with light. Christ, as a continual sun, enlightens it with his beams.

Thomas Watson, A Body of Divinity 5.8

What can be said about heaven

10 passages · 7 writers · 300s to 1900s

Writers say how far heaven can be described or known, and some warn against speculation.

c. 362–389

If it had been permitted to Paul to utter what the Third Heaven contained, and his own advance, or ascension, or assumption thither, perhaps we should know something more about God’s Nature, if this was the mystery of the rapture. But since it was ineffable, we too will honour it by silence.

Gregory of Nazianzus, Select Orations of Saint Gregory Nazianzen 14

413–426

But as we do not know what degree of perfection the spiritual body shall attain,—for here we speak of a matter of which we have no experience, and upon which the authority of Scripture does not definitely pronounce,—it is necessary that the words of the Book of Wisdom be illustrated in us: “The thoughts of mortal men are timid, and our fore-castings uncertain.”

Augustine of Hippo, City of God 22.29

1677

But then we must see that our notions of heaven be not gross and carnal, that we dream not of a Mahometan paradise, nor rest on those metaphors and similitudes by which these joys are sometimes represented: for this might perhaps have a quite contrary effect; it might entangle us farther in carnal affections, and we should be ready to indulge ourselves in a very liberal foretaste of those pleasures wherein we had placed our everlasting felicity.

Henry Scougal, The Life of God in the Soul of Man 3

Passing mentions

Holiness and grace required for entry

12 passages · 11 writers · 300s to 1900s

Writers mention that heaven is closed to the unholy and open to those made fit by grace.

c. 398–404

I entreat you, let us conceive some desire for those blessings, let us long for that Bridegroom, let us be virgins as to the true Virginity. For the Lord seeks after the virginity of the soul. With this let us enter into Heaven, “not having spot, or wrinkle, or any such thing” ( Eph. v. 27 )

John Chrysostom, The Homilies of St. John Chrysostom on the Epistle to the Hebrews 32

1674

Unless this uncleanness of sin be purged and washed away, we can never come unto the enjoyment of God: “Nothing that defileth shall in any wise enter into the new Jerusalem,” Rev. xxi. 27. To suppose that an unpurified sinner can be brought unto the blessed enjoyment of God, is to overthrow both the law and the gospel, and to say that Christ died in vain.

John Owen, Pneumatologia 4.4

1930–1933

Shall see God (τον θεον οψοντα). Without holiness no man will see the Lord in heaven (Heb 12:14 ). The Beatific Vision is only possible here on earth to those with pure hearts. No other can see the King now.

A.T. Robertson, Word Pictures in the New Testament 2.5

Heaven as reward

8 passages · 8 writers · 100s to 1800s

Writers mention heaven as a reward or recompense, and some say it is graded or given freely.

c. 190–202

For there are with the Lord both rewards and “many mansions,” corresponding to men’s lives. “Whosoever shall receive,” says He, “a prophet in the name of a prophet, shall receive a prophet’s reward; and whosoever shall receive a righteous man in the name of a righteous man, shall receive a righteous man’s reward; and whoso shall receive one of the least of these my disciples, shall not lose his reward.” And again, the differences of virtue according to merit, and the noble rewards, He indicated by the hours unequal in number; and in addition, by the equal reward given to each of the labourers—that is, salvation, which is meant by the penny—He indicated the equality of justice; and the difference of those called He intimated, by those who worked for unequal portions of time.

Clement of Alexandria, The Stromata, or Miscellanies 4.5

c. 238–270

All who have possessed themselves of the stainless robe of temperance shall be received into the mystical bride-chamber of righteousness. All who have come nearer the angelic degree than others shall also enter into the more real enjoyment of their Lord’s beatitude. All who have possessed the illuminating oil of understanding, and the pure incense of conscience, shall inherit the promise of spiritual favour and the spiritual adoption.

Gregory Thaumaturgus, Dubious or Spurious Writings of Gregory Thaumaturgus 5.2

c. 386–407

And not only in hell, but also in the kingdom one will find many differences; for He saith “in my Fathers house are many mansions;” and, “there is one glory of the sun, and another glory of the moon.” And what wonder, if in dealing with such great matters he has spoken with such precision, seeing that He declares there is a difference in that world even between one star and another?

John Chrysostom, An Exhortation to Theodore After His Fall 3

1873

As the rewards of heaven are given on the ground of the merits of Christ, and as He has a right to do what He will with his own, there would be no injustice were the thief saved on the cross as highly exalted as the Apostle Paul. But the general drift of Scripture is in favour of the doctrine that a man shall reap what he sows; that God will reward every one according to, although not on account of his works.

Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology III.18.6

Heaven as homeland and the Father's house

11 passages · 11 writers · 300s to 1900s

Writers mention heaven as home, true country, citizenship, or the Father's house.

c. 362–389

My friend, every one that is of high mind has one Country, the Heavenly Jerusalem, in which we store up our Citizenship. All have one family—if you look at what is here below the dust—or if you look higher, that Inbreathing of which we are partakers, and which we were bidden to keep, and with which I must stand before my Judge to give an account of my heavenly nobility, and of the Divine Image. … And these earthly countries and families are the playthings of this our temporary life and scene. For our country is whatever each may have first occupied, either as tyrant, or in misfortune; and in this we are all alike strangers and pilgrims, however much we may play with names.

Gregory of Nazianzus, Select Orations of Saint Gregory Nazianzen 18

c. 370–419

Hereafter there shall come—yes, there shall come—a day when you will return a victor to your true country, and will walk through the heavenly Jerusalem crowned with the crown of valor. Then will you receive the citizenship thereof with Paul.

Jerome, The Letters of St. Jerome 14

1668

Desponding soul, doth it become a man or woman travelling upon the road to that heavenly city, and almost arrived there, within a few days journey of his Father's house, where all his wants shall be supplied, to talk on thus about a little meat, drink or clothes, which he fears he shall want by the way? It was a noble saying of the forty martyrs, famous in the ecclesiastical story, when turned out naked in a frosty night to be starved to death, with these words they comforted one another: The winter indeed is sharp and cold, but heaven is warm and comfortable; here we shiver for cold, but Abraham's bosom will make amends for all.

John Flavel, A Saint Indeed 9

The heavenly Jerusalem

12 passages · 11 writers · 100s to 1800s

Writers mention the heavenly Jerusalem or Zion as the church, a city, or the final home of the saints.

180

When these things, therefore, pass away above the earth, John, the Lord’s disciple, says that the new Jerusalem above shall [then] descend, as a bride adorned for her husband; and that this is the tabernacle of God, in which God will dwell with men.

Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies: Book V 36

c. 290–300

For the Holy Spirit does not speak of that well-known town in Judea; but truly of that heavenly city, the blessed Jerusalem, which He declares to be the assembly of the souls which God plainly promises to place first, “above His chief joy,” in the new dispensation, settling those who are clothed in the most white robe of virginity in the pure dwelling of unapproachable light; because they had it not in mind to put off their wedding garment—that is, to relax their minds by wandering thoughts.

Methodius of Olympus, The Banquet of the Ten Virgins; or Concerning Chastity 5.5

1535

The earthly Jerusalem with its ordinances and laws represents Hagar and her offspring. They are slaves to the Law, sin and death. But the heavenly Jerusalem is Sarah, the free woman. This heavenly Jerusalem is the Church, that is to say the number of all believers throughout the world, having one and the same Gospel, one and the same faith in Christ, one and the same Holy Ghost, and the same sacraments.

Martin Luther, Commentary on Galatians 4:26

The renewed creation

11 passages · 10 writers · 200s to 1900s

Writers mention new heavens and a new earth, and whether the present world is renewed or replaced.

c. 220–250

From all which I am of opinion, so far as I can see, that this order of the human race has been appointed in order that in the future world, or in ages to come, when there shall be the new heavens and new earth, spoken of by Isaiah, it may be restored to that unity promised by the Lord Jesus in His prayer to God the Father on behalf of His disciples: … And in keeping with this is the declaration of the same apostle, when he exhorts us, who even in the present life are placed in the Church, in which is the form of that kingdom which is to come, to this same similitude of unity: “That ye all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you; but that ye be perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.”

Origen of Alexandria, The Works of Origen 2.6

1540–1564

Heaven and earth, he says, shall pass away for our sakes; is it meet, then, for us to be engrossed with the things of earth, and not, on the contrary, to attend to a holy and godly life? The corruptions of heaven and earth will be purged by fire, while yet as the creatures of God they are pure; what then ought to be done by us who are full of so many pollutions? As to the word godlinesses ( pietatibus ,) the plural number is used for the singular, except you take it as meaning the duties of godliness. Of the elements of the world I shall only say this one thing, that they are to be consumed, only that they may be renovated, their substance still remaining the same, as it may be easily gathered from Romans 8:21 , and from other passages.

John Calvin, Commentary on the Catholic Epistles 2 Peter 3.3

1930–1933

A new heaven and a new earth (ουρανον καινον κα γην καινην). This new vision (ειδον) is the picture of the bliss of the saints.

A.T. Robertson, Word Pictures in the New Testament 28.21

Seeing and enjoying God

10 passages · 8 writers · 200s to 1800s

Writers mention the sight or enjoyment of God as the end of the Christian life.

c. 440–461

For the unspeakable and unapproachable vision of the Godhead Itself which is reserved till eternal life for the pure in heart, they could in no wise look upon and see while still surrounded with mortal flesh. The Lord displays His glory, therefore, before chosen witnesses, and invests that bodily shape which He shared with others with such splendour, that His face was like the sun’s brightness and His garments equalled the whiteness of snow.

Leo the Great, The Letters and Sermons of Leo the Great 5.26

1120–1153

And so what but the consummation of wisdom is that glorification which we hope for at the last from the vision of God that will make us like Him?

Bernard of Clairvaux, Some Letters of Saint Bernard 41

1668

O then! who would not be willing to die for a full sight and enjoyment of God? Methinks thy soul should look and sigh, like a prisoner, through the grates of this mortality; O that I had wings like a dove! then would I fly away and be at rest: most men need patience to die; but a saint that understands what death admits him to, should rather need patience to live; methinks he should often look out, and listen on a death-bed for his Lord's coming; and when he receives the news of his approaching change, should say, The voice of my beloved!

John Flavel, A Saint Indeed 16

1708

The darkness of our present state in comparison with the vision of God, which will be the happiness of heaven, where the divine glory is unveiled. Now we can only say what he is not, but then we shall see him as he is.

Matthew Henry, Commentary on First Kings 8.1

Risen bodies and the angels

10 passages · 7 writers · 300s to 1900s

Writers mention the risen body and likeness to the angels, including the absence of marriage.

337–345

For our Lord said:— They that are worthy of that world, and of that resurrection from the abode of the dead, shall not take wives, nor shall (women) become wives to men; for they cannot die; but they are as the angels in heaven, and are the children of God . And the apostle said:— There is neither male nor female, neither bond nor free; but ye are all one in Jesus Christ . For, as for Eve, to spread abroad generation, God took her out from Adam, that she might become the mother of all living; but yet in that world there is no female; even as in heaven also there is no female, nor generation, nor use of concupiscence.

Aphrahat, Aphrahat:  Select Demonstrations 10

396–397

Now we see with our eyes, hear with our ears, act with our hands, walk with our feet. But in that spiritual body we shall be all sight, all hearing, all action, all movement. The Lord shall transfigure the body of our humiliation and fashion it according to His own glorious body. In saying transfigure he affirms identity with the members which we now have. But a different body, spiritual and ethereal, is promised to us, which is neither tangible, nor perceptible to the eye, nor ponderable; and the change it undergoes will be suitable to the difference in its future abode.

Jerome, To Pammachius against John of Jerusalem 99

413–426

Jesus Himself also, when asked by the Sadducees, who denied the resurrection, which of the seven brothers should have to wife the woman whom all in succession had taken to raise up seed to their brother, as the law enjoined, says, “Ye do err, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God.” And though it was a fit opportunity for His saying, She about whom you make inquiries shall herself be a man, and not a woman, He said nothing of the kind; but “In the resurrection they neither marry nor are given in marriage, but are as the angels of God in heaven.” They shall be equal to the angels in immortality and happiness, not in flesh, nor in resurrection, which the angels did not need, because they could not die.

Augustine of Hippo, City of God 22.17

Inheritance and rest

10 passages · 9 writers · 100s to 1900s

Writers mention heaven as an inheritance or a rest, often through Canaan and the Sabbath.

1418–1427

ABOVE all things and in all things, O my soul, rest always in God, for He is the everlasting rest of the saints.

Thomas à Kempis, The Imitation of Christ 3.21

1674

Children are heirs unto their father; and those who are children of God are heirs of that inheritance which God hath provided for his children, “heirs of God.” And all the good things of grace and glory which believers are made partakers of in this world or that which is to come are called their “inheritance,” because they are the effects of free, gratuitous adoption.

John Owen, Pneumatologia 9.9

1746

It is grace that is the seed of glory and dawning of glory in the heart, and therefore it is grace that is the earnest of the future inheritance. What is it that is the beginning or earnest of eternal life in the soul, but spiritual life; and what is that but grace? The inheritance that Christ has purchased for the elect, is the Spirit of God; not in any extraordinary gifts, but in his vital indwelling in the heart, exerting and communicating himself there, in his own proper, holy, or divine nature; and this is the sum total of the inheritance that Christ purchased for the elect.

Jonathan Edwards, Religious Affections 3.1

1871

The Old Testament promise of Canaan to Israel typified "the good word of God's" promise of the heavenly rest (Heb 4:1-16). Therefore, there immediately follows the clause, "the powers of the world to come."

Robert Jamieson, A.R. Fausset, and David Brown, Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible Hebrews 6

Joy, praise, and company

9 passages · 9 writers · 300s to 1900s

Writers mention heaven as joyful company, worship, and feasting.

c. 329–373

It becomes us then in these days of the Passover, to rise early with the saints, and approach the Lord with all our soul, with purity of body, with confession and godly faith in Him; so that when we have here first drunk, and are filled with these divine waters which [flow] from Him, we may be able to sit at table with the saints in heaven, and may share in the one voice of gladness which is there. From this sinners, because it wearied them, are rightly cast out, and hear the words, ‘Friend, how camest thou in hither, not having a wedding garment ?’

Athanasius of Alexandria, Letters of Athanasius with Two Ancient Chronicles of His Life 3.3.16

375

Just as when a sunbeam falls on bright and transparent bodies, they themselves become brilliant too, and shed forth a fresh brightness from themselves, so souls wherein the Spirit dwells, illuminated by the Spirit, themselves become spiritual, and send forth their grace to others. Hence comes foreknowledge of the future, understanding of mysteries, apprehension of what is hidden, distribution of good gifts, the heavenly citizenship, a place in the chorus of angels, joy without end, abiding in God, the being made like to God, and, highest of all, the being made God.

Basil of Caesarea, De Spiritu Sancto 10

Heaven begun now

7 passages · 7 writers · 300s to 1900s

Writers mention a foretaste or earnest of heaven in the present life.

1418–1427

That good and sweet feeling which you sometimes have is the effect of present grace and a certain foretaste of your heavenly home. You must not lean upon it too much, because it comes and goes.

Thomas à Kempis, The Imitation of Christ 3.6

1938

The Kingdom of God is already present, eternal life is realized in principle, the Spirit is the earnest of the heavenly inheritance, and believers are already seated with Christ in heavenly places. But while some of the eschatological realities are thus projected into the present, they are not fully realized until the time of the future consummation. And when we speak of "eschatology," we have in mind more particularly the facts and events that are connected with the second coming of Christ, and that will mark the end of the present dispensation and will usher in the eternal glories of the future.

Louis Berkhof, Systematic Theology 6.1

1938

We shall see ourselves vitally connected with, joined to, this heavenly Christ, so that we have been received in Christ as belonging to heaven, “even as He”; that we are “the righteousness of God in Him”; that we are loved even as He; and that our citizenship is in heaven. Our hearts must be convinced that these things are facts, not figures of speech, or things to be realized in some far future. We wait, indeed, for the redemption of our bodies, but we ourselves are already in the new creation, and for us old things (all earthly things, “religious” or worldly), have passed away.

William R. Newell, Romans Verse-by-Verse 16

The departed and the saints in heaven

11 passages · 11 writers · 100s to 1800s

Writers mention the dead in Christ, their rest, and what they know and do.

c. 370–419

Before Christ’s coming Abraham is in the lower regions: after Christ’s coming the robber is in paradise. And therefore at His rising again “many bodies of the saints which slept arose, and were seen in the heavenly Jerusalem.” … The flaming sword that keeps the way of paradise and the cherubim that are stationed at its doors are alike quenched and unloosed by the blood of Christ. It is not surprising that this should be promised us in the resurrection: for as many of us as living in the flesh do not live after the flesh, have our citizenship in heaven, and while we are still here on earth we are told that “the kingdom of heaven is within us.”

Jerome, The Letters of St. Jerome 60

1120–1153

But on what principle shall a death be accounted joyful which is not accompanied by the joys of heaven? or from whence should a dying person derive joy who was sure that he was going down into the darkness of the prison-house, and yet did not bear with him any certitude, how soon the consolation of a deliverer thence should come to him? Thus it was that when one of the saints heard Set thy house in order, for thou shalt die, and not live, he turned himself to the wall and wept bitterly, and so asked and obtained some deferring of hateful death.

Bernard of Clairvaux, Some Letters of Saint Bernard 45

1755–1765

The marriage of the Lamb is come - Is near at hand, to be solemnized speedily. What this implies, none of "the spirits of just men," even in paradise, yet know.

John Wesley, Notes on the Bible 27.19

Where heaven is and who is there

1 passage · 1 writer · 200s

Writers mention heaven as the place Christ entered at the ascension.

c. 258–304

The new testament is announced as an open door in heaven. “And the first voice which I heard was , as it were, of a trumpet talking with me, saying, Come up hither.”] Since the door is shown to be opened, it is manifest that previously it had been closed to men. And it was sufficiently and fully laid open when Christ ascended with His body to the Father into heaven.

Victorinus of Pettau, Commentary on the Apocalypse of the Blessed John 4

What has not been seen or imagined

4 passages · 4 writers · 300s to 1800s

Writers mention that the good things of heaven have not been seen or imagined, and that some questions about heaven stay open.

1869–1873

If St. Paul “could not utter” the things that he saw in the third heaven and called them “unspeakable things,” it is not strange that Lazarus should say nothing of what he saw in Paradise (2 Cor. 12:4). But there may be always seen in Scripture a striking silence about the feelings of men and women who have been the subjects of remarkable Divine interposition.

J.C. Ryle, Expository Thoughts on John 11:38-46