The Monastic Pint Answers from church history on today's questions

What does heaven look like?

What Christian writers said, from about AD 195 to 1930.

50 passages · 25 writers · 9 centuries

The short answer

Bayly, Edwards, and Barnes describe the New Jerusalem of Revelation 21-22 as a city of gold with pearl gates and walls of jasper or precious stones. Ryle and Brown take the many mansions of John 14:2 as room for all believers in the Father's house, and Barnes says this is the common understanding. Tong says the Lord God Almighty and the Lamb are the temple of the new Jerusalem, Bayly says the glory of God lights the city so that it needs no sun or moon, and Spurgeon says the Lamb is the temple and the light of heaven. Barnes and Bullinger read the river and tree of life as Paradise regained, and Spurgeon says the heavenly Paradise is fuller and more abundant than Eden. Barnes, Maclaren, Newton, and Finney take the images as figures, Bullinger says the final visions are all literal and real, and Wesley takes the gold, pearls, and gates as figurative and the measures as real.

The many mansions of John 14:2

11 passages · 10 writers · 300s to 1900s

Ryle says heaven is a place of many mansions with room for all believers, Brown says the many mansions mean room for all and a place for each, and Barnes says the word is commonly understood as ample room to receive all who will come. Barnes adds that some have understood the mansions as different grades in the joys of heaven, with some nearer to God than others. Edersheim says the many mansions, or rather stations, are all in the one Father's house. Augustine says the mansions already exist in predestination and are being prepared through the purifying by faith of the hearts of those who will inhabit them. Jerome says they are heavenly mansions in the kingdom of heaven, not churches scattered on earth.

c. 406–421 · Augustine of Hippo, Tractates on the Gospel of John (In Iohannis Evangelium Tractatus CXXIV) 69.1

We have now the opportunity, dearly beloved, as far as we can, of understanding the earlier words of the Lord from the later, and His previous statements by those that follow, in what you have heard was His answer to the question of the Apostle Thomas. For when the Lord was speaking above of the mansions, of which He both said that they already were in His Father’s house, and that He was going to prepare them; where we understood that those mansions already existed in predestination, and are also being prepared through the purifying by faith of the hearts of those who are hereafter to inhabit them, seeing that they themselves are the very house of God; and what else is it to dwell in God’s house than to be in the number of His people, since His people are at the same time in God, and God in them? To make this preparation the Lord departed, that by believing in Him, though no longer visible, the mansion, whose outward form is always hid in the future, may now by faith be prepared: for this reason, therefore, He had said, “And if I go away and prepare a place for you, I will come again, and receive you to myself; that where I am, there ye may be also.

1692 · Thomas Watson, A Body of Divinity, Contained in Sermons upon the Westminster Assembly's Catechism 7.1

2 Cor 5:5: Here the saints are straitened for room; they have but mean cottages to live in; but they shall have a royal palace to live in hereafter. Here is their sojourning house, there in heaven is their mansionhouse, a house built high above all the visible orbs, bespangled with light, and enriched with pearls and precious stones. Col 1:12, and Rev 21:19. It is not their landlord's house, but their Father's house, and stands upon consecrated ground.

1834 · Albert Barnes, Notes on the Bible: John 14.2

In my Father's house - Most interpreters understand this of heaven, as the special dwelling-place or palace of God; but it may include the universe, as the abode of the omnipresent God. Are many mansions - The word rendered "mansions" means either the act of dwelling in any place (Joh 14:23, "we will make our abode with him"), or it means the place where one dwells. It is taken from the verb to remain, and signifies the place where one dwells or remains. It is applied by the Greek writers to the tents or temporary habitations which soldiers pitch in their marches. It denotes a dwelling of less permanency than the word house. It is commonly understood as affirming that in heaven there is ample room to receive all who will come; that therefore the disciples might be sure that they would not be excluded. Some have understood it as affirming that there will be different grades in the joys of heaven; that some of the mansions of the saints will be nearer to God than others, agreeably to Co1 15:40-41.

1856–1869 · J. C. Ryle, Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: John 14.1-3

Believers are in a strange land, and at school, in this life. In the life to come they will be at home. Heaven is a place of "MANSIONS"--of lasting, permanent, and eternal dwellings. Here in the body we are in temporary lodgings, tents, and tabernacles, and must submit to many changes. In heaven we shall be settled at last, and go out no more. "Here we have no continuing city." (Heb. 13:14.) Our house not made with hands shall never be taken down. Heaven is a place of "MANY mansions." There will be room for all believers and room for all sorts, for little saints as well as great ones, for the weakest believer as well as for the strongest. The feeblest child of God need not fear there will be no place for him.

The city, its gates, temple, and light

19 passages · 14 writers · 100s to 1900s

Bayly, Edwards, and Barnes describe the city as built of gold, with walls of jasper or precious stones and gates each made of a single pearl. Tong says the city has three gates on each of its four sides, signifying free entrance from all quarters of the earth. Tong says the Lord God Almighty and the Lamb are the temple of the new Jerusalem, and Henry says the New Jerusalem had no temple in it. Henry says heaven needs no sun or moon because its light will swallow up the light of the sun, and Bayly says the glory of God lights the city so that no sun or moon is needed. Spurgeon says the Lamb is the temple of heaven and the light of heaven.

c. 1611 · Lewis Bayly, The Practice of Piety 3

The Holy Ghost framing himself to our weakness, describes the glory of that place (which no man can estimate) by such things as are most precious in the estimation of man; and therefore likeneth it to a great and holy city, named the heavenly Jerusalem (Rev. xxi. 2, &c.), where only God and his people who are saved, and written in the Lamb’s book (ver. 24 & 27), do inhabit; all built of pure gold, like unto clear glass or crystal (ver. 11, 18, 19, 20;) the walls of jasper-stone: the foundations of the walls garnished with twelve manner of precious stones, having twelve gates, each built of one pearl (ver. 21:) three gates towards each of the four corners of the world (ver. 13), and at each gate an angel (ver. 12), as so many porters, that no unclean thing should enter into it (ver. 27.) It is four square (ver. 16), therefore perfect: the length, the breadth, and height of it are equal, 12,000 furlongs every way; therefore glorious and spacious. Through the midst of her streets ever runneth a pure river of the water of life, as clear as crystal (Rev. xxii. 1); and on the other side the river is the tree of life (ver. 2), ever growing, which bears twelve manner of fruits, and gives fruit every month; and the leaves of the tree are health to the nations.

1740 · Jonathan Edwards, The Portion of the Righteous 1

Heaven is here represented by a city, whose very walls were made of precious stones. And the foundations were also all precious stones, and the gates were each a single pearl, and the very streets of the city were of pure gold; and yet it was something so excellent, as it appeared to John, that his comparing it to pure gold did not represent the excellency of it; it had also the beautiful transparency of clear glass. The apostle could find nothing on earth excellent enough adequately to represent its surpassing beauty.

The river and tree of life

9 passages · 9 writers · 200s to 1900s

Barnes says the river of life alludes to the river that watered the first Eden, and that the description is of Eden recovered, or Paradise regained. Bullinger says Paradise is a definite place, lost in Genesis 3, and that the final visions show it regained, with the tree of life and the water of life as its chief marks. Edwards says the New Jerusalem is called the Paradise of God and that the river seems to allude to the river in Eden, and Tong says the heavenly state is a paradise restored by the second Adam. Spurgeon says everything in the heavenly Paradise is fuller than in Eden: gold paves the streets, the river has no earthly source, and the trees bear twelve fruits in the year. Fausset says the water of life is infinitely superior to the waters of the first Paradise, and Wesley says the tree of life is many trees, bearing fruit every month, whose leaves keep the nations in health.

1748 · Jonathan Edwards, An Humble Attempt to Promote Explicit Agreement and Visible Union of God's People in Extraordinary Prayer 3

The new Jerusalem is called in this book the Paradise of God; and therefore is represented as having the tree of life growing in it, (Rev. ii.7. chap. ii. 7. and Rev. xxii. 2.) And it being described, as though a river ran through the midst of it, there seems to be some allusion to the ancient paradise in Eden, of which we are told that there ran a river through the midst of it to water it; (Gen. ii. 10.) i. e. to supply the plants of it with nourishment.

1834 · Albert Barnes, Notes on the Bible: Revelation 22.1

See the notes on Joh 4:14. The allusion here is doubtless to the first Eden, where a river watered the garden (Gen 2:10, seq.), and as this is a description of Eden recovered, or Paradise regained, it was natural to introduce a river of water also, yet in such a way as to accord with the general description of that future abode of the redeemed. It does not spring up, therefore, from the ground, but flows from the throne of God and the Lamb. Perhaps, also, the writer had in his eye the description in Eze 47:1-12, where a stream issues from under the temple, and is parted in different directions.

1875 · Charles Haddon Spurgeon, Spurgeon's Sermons, Volume 21 (1875) 1233

Everything in the Divine Paradise is fuller and more abundant. The gold, which in Eden lay in the soil, is used in the heavenly Paradise to pave the streets. The river has no earthly source, but is "a pure river of the Water of Life, clear as crystal, proceeding out of the Throne of God and of the Lamb." The Lord, who in Eden walked only at solemn intervals, "among the trees of the garden in the cool of the day," has, in Heaven, His Tabernacle among men and dwells among them, while the trees which grew in Eden, and ripened their fruits only in autumn, are succeeded by trees with 12 fruitages in the year.

Symbol or literal

11 passages · 10 writers · 300s to 1900s

Barnes says the city is the natural emblem of the heavenly world, carried out as an image, and Finney says the gates and walls of the New Jerusalem present the glories of heaven in symbol. Maclaren says the picture is a shadow and the figures are representations, not adequate presentations, and Newton says the white robe, golden harp, palm branch, and crown are emblems of the honour and happiness of heaven. Jerome asks how a square city with length and breadth equal to its height, walls of jasper, and a whole city of pure gold can be taken as described. Bullinger says the final visions of Paradise regained are all literal and real. Wesley says the gold, pearls, walls, foundations, and gates are figurative, but that the spiritual bodies are real bodies and the measures are real and determinate.

1754 · John Wesley, Explanatory Notes on Revelation 21.15

In treating of all these things a deep reverence is necessary; and so is a measure of spiritual wisdom; that we may neither understand them too literally and grossly, nor go too far from the natural force of the words. The gold, the pearls, the precious stones, the walls, foundations, gates, are undoubtedly figurative expressions; seeing the city itself is in glory, and the inhabitants of it have spiritual bodies: yet these spiritual bodies are also real bodies, and the city is an abode distinct from its inhabitants, and proportioned to them who take up a finite and a determinate space. The measures, therefore, above mentioned are real and determinate.

1834 · Albert Barnes, Notes on the Bible: Revelation 21.intro

Jerusalem was regarded as the unique dwelling-place of God, and to the Hebrews it became thus the natural emblem or symbol of the heavenly world. The conception having occurred of describing the future condition of the righteous under the image of a beautiful city, all that follows is in "keeping" with that, and is merely a carrying out of the image. It is a city with beautiful walls and gates; a city that has no temple - for it is all a temple; a city that needs no light - for God is its light; a city into which nothing impure ever enters; a city filled with trees, and streams, and fountains, and fruits - the "Paradise Regained."

1909 · Alexander Maclaren, Expositions of Holy Scripture: Romans 8.17

Do not then rest in the symbols that show us, darkly and far off, what that future glory is. Do not forget that the picture is a shadow. Get beneath all these figurative expressions, and feel that whilst it may be true that for us in our present earthly state, there can be no higher, no purer, no more spiritual nor any truer representations of the blessedness which is to come, than those which couch it in the forms of earthly experience, and appeal to sense as the minister of delight—yet that all these things are representations, and not adequate presentations.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.