The Monastic Pint Answers from church history on today's questions

Romans 15:13: the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace

What Christian writers said, from about AD 386 to 1938.

27 passages · 11 writers · 6 centuries

The short answer

Spurgeon and Evans say God is called the God of hope because he is the object of hope and the one who works it in believers. Spurgeon says the joy and peace believers have are meant to be a platform from which they abound in hope by the power of the Holy Spirit, and Maclaren says hope springs from the experience of joy and peace. Chrysostom says the filling with joy comes on condition of the believer's contributing his part, which is why Paul says "in believing." On Romans 15:4, Evans and Moule say the Scriptures were written so that believers might have hope. Evans says hope not fastened upon God is but fancy.

God as the God of hope

9 passages · 7 writers · 1500s to 1900s

Evans and Spurgeon say God is both the object of hope and the one who works it in believers. Calvin reads "the God of hope" as the God in whom we all hope, who fills believers with joy, unity, and concord by believing, and Owen says the power of the Holy Ghost extends to hope and to peace in believing.

c. 1714 · John Evans, Commentary on Romans 15.13

God is the God of hope. He is the foundation on which our hope is built, and he is the builder that doth himself raise it: he is both the object of our hope, and the author of it. That hope is but fancy, and will deceive us, which is not fastened upon God (as the goodness hoped for, and the truth hoped in), and which is not of his working in us. We have both together, Ps. cxix. 49. Thy word—there is God the object; on which thou hast caused me to hope—there is God the author of our hope, 1 Pet. i. 3.

1877 · Charles Haddon Spurgeon, Spurgeon's Sermons, Volume 23 (1877) 1384

Our God is, however, called the God of Hope, not only because He is the Object of our hope and the ground of our joy and peace, but because He it is that works hope and joy in us. No joy is worth having unless the Lord is the beginning and the end of it. And no joy is worth receiving unless it springs from hope in Him. He must breathe peace upon us, or else the storm-tossed waters of our spirit will never rest—nor is it desirable that they should—for peace without God is stupefaction, joy without God is madness and hope without God is presumption! In true Believers their hope, faith, joy and peace are all of Divine workmanship.

Joy and peace in believing

12 passages · 6 writers · 300s to 1900s

Spurgeon and Maclaren say joy and peace lead to abounding hope, while Evans and Manton say joy and peace arise from hope. Spurgeon and Newell tie abounding hope to the power of the Holy Spirit. Chrysostom says the filling is not simply from the Spirit but on condition of the believer's part, which is why Paul says "in believing."

c. 386–398 · John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Epistle to the Romans 28

But it is not simply from the Spirit, but on condition of our contributing our part also. This is why he says, “in believing.” For this is the way for you to be filled with joy, if ye believe, if ye hope. Yet he does not say if ye hope, but, “if ye abound in hope,” so as not to find comfort in troubles only, but even to have joy through the abundance of faith and hope.

c. 1714 · John Evans, Commentary on Romans 15.13

The joy and peace of believers arise chiefly from their hopes. What is laid out upon them is but little, compared with what is laid up for them; therefore the more hope they have the more joy and peace they have. We do then abound in hope when we hope for great things from God, and are greatly established and confirmed in these hopes. Christians should desire and labour after an abundance of hope, such hope as will not make ashamed. This is through the power of the Holy Ghost. The same almighty power that works grace begets and strengthens this hope. Our own power will never reach it; and therefore where this hope is, and is abounding, the blessed Spirit must have all the glory.

1909 · Alexander Maclaren, Expositions of Holy Scripture: Romans 15.4-13

So much then for the genealogy of one form of the Christian hope. But we have also a hope that is born of the day, the child of sunshine and gladness; and that is set before us in the second of the two verses which we are considering, ‘The God of hope fill you with all joy and peace in believing, that ye may abound in hope.’ So then, ‘the darkness and the light are both alike’ to our hope, in so far as each may become the occasion for its exercise. It is not only to be the sweet juice expressed from our hearts by the winepress of calamities, but that which flows of itself from hearts ripened and mellowed under the sunshine of God-given blessedness. We have seen that the bridge by which sorrow led to hope, is perseverance and courage; in this second analysis of the origin of hope, joy and peace are the bridge by which Faith passes over into it. Observe the difference: there is no direct connection between affliction and hope, but there is between joy and hope. We have no right to say, ‘Because I suffer, I shall possess good in the future’; but we have a right to say, ‘Because I rejoice’—of course with a joy in God—‘I shall never cease to rejoice in Him.’ Such joy is the prophet of its own immortality and completion. And, on the other hand, the joy and peace which are naturally the direct progenitors of Christian hope, are the children of faith. So that we have here two generations, as it were, of hope’s ancestors;—Faith produces joy and peace, and these again produce hope.

Hope through the patience and comfort of the Scriptures (15:4)

6 passages · 5 writers · 1700s to 1900s

Evans and Moule say the Scriptures were written so that believers might have hope. Maclaren speaks of a bridge from sorrow and despair to hope, and Spurgeon says the Scriptures always produce hope in those who believe, obey, and follow them. Barnes says the way to find support in afflictions is to go to the Bible.

c. 1714 · John Evans, Commentary on Romans 15.1-4

Secondly, That we through patience and comfort of the scriptures might have hope. That hope which hath eternal life for its object is here proposed as the end of scripture-learning. The scripture was written that we might know what to hope for from God, and upon what grounds, and in what way. This should recommend the scripture to us that it is a special friend to Christian hope.

1909 · Alexander Maclaren, Expositions of Holy Scripture: Romans 15.4-13

We cannot pass from the black frowning cliffs on one side of the gorge to the sunny tablelands on the other without a bridge—and the bridge for a poor soul from the blackness of sorrow, and the sharp grim rocks of despair, to the smiling pastures of hope, with all their half-open blossoms, is builded in that Book, which tells us the meaning and purpose of them all; and is full of the histories of those who have fought and overcome, have hoped and not been ashamed. Scripture is given for this among other reasons, that it may encourage us, and so may produce in us this great grace of active patience, if we may call it so. The first thing to notice is, how Scripture gives encouragement—for such rather than consolation is the meaning of the word. It is much to dry tears, but it is more to stir the heart as with a trumpet call.